ST: We can barely stay afloat, say low-income folk
-
We can barely stay afloat, say low-income folk
Some MPs and social workers say pleas for financial aid from poorer residents are growing louder and more frequent with the rising cost of living
Sunday Times, The (Singapore)
News
December 2, 2007
Author: Jamie Ee Wen Wei and Nur Dianah Suhaimi
ADMINISTRATIVE assistant Noor Zeen earns $1,350 a month and has not paid her utility bills for the past four months.
Prices of everyday goods have gone up and she finds that she no longer earns enough to cover household expenses.
The 28-year-old divorcee said her monthly utility bill alone has gone up by at least $20. The breadwinner in her family, she lives in a four-room flat in Hougang with her mother, her eight-year-old son and her late aunt's two children.
Cash-strapped and with unpaid utility bills of about $600, Madam Noor asked her MP, Madam Cynthia Phua (Aljunied GRC), for financial help last week.
After the soft-spoken woman poured out her financial woes, Madam Phua put her on short-term financial assistance that will provide her with $200 for the next three months.
The economy may be buoyant, but low-wage earners such as Madam Noor have been telling MPs and social workers that they can barely stay afloat because the cost of living has been going up.
These workers say that their wages are not rising as fast as inflation.
In October, inflation rose to a 16-year high of 3.6 per cent. Two months ago, prices of food staples such as bread and noodles went up by 20 per cent. Soaring oil prices have also driven up pump prices and electricity tariffs.
Median monthly starting pay for cleaners and labourers has in fact fallen by nearly one-third, from $860 to $600, between 1996 and last year.
Twelve MPs and social workers interviewed said pleas for financial help from residents are growing louder but most could not give figures.
In Jalan Besar GRC, MP Lily Neo said she sees about 60 hard-luck cases a week at her Meet-the-People sessions. In the past, she saw about 40 cases.
She said: 'Each week, I find myself busier and busier, staying longer and longer, because there are so many people asking for financial help.''
Madam Halimah Yacob, an MP for Jurong GRC, said some of the low-income residents are holding two jobs and doing overtime, yet they still ask for rations of basic items such as cooking oil and Milo because they do not earn enough to feed their families.
Mr Zaqy Mohamad (Hong Kah GRC) observed that those on financial aid schemes are showing up more often at Meet-the-People Sessions.
'They used to come once every three months. Now, some come back every couple of weeks to ask for food and utility vouchers,' he said, because their cash is running out faster.
Mr Charles Chong (Pasir Ris-Punggol GRC) said he was even told off by a retiree who had asked for financial aid.
The elderly man told the MP: 'I'm retired, in my 60s, have no job and living off my savings. But GST is up, food prices are up, inflation is up. The only thing that has not gone up is the banks' interest rates!'
Mr Sim Boon Choon, 68, is in the same boat as the retiree. He tries to stretch every cent of the $290 in public assistance that he receives every month.
A loaf of bread now costs 20 cents more and the price of a packet of 20 Milo sachets is up by 40 cents. Even chicken rice and kway teow soup at the hawker centre cost 50 cents more.
To save money, he has stopped eating out for all his meals. Dinner is a simple meal of bread and Milo. To save electricity, the bachelor does not switch on the lights in his one-room Telok Blangah flat.
Even then, he finds himself running out of money before the month is up. 'I'm already very thrifty but the money is still not enough,' he said in Hokkien.
In March, public welfare recipients such as Mr Sim had their monthly allowance raised from $260 to $290 to offset the impact of the GST hike and rising cost of living.
But social workers said the $30 increment is not enough, given that inflation has risen so high.
Ms Grace Lee, centre director of Care Corner Family Service Centre (Toa Payoh), said the centre has been receiving more requests for the monthly free food packages of rice, instant noodles and canned food.
At least 100 packages are handed out, compared to 80 a few months back.
Over at the Care Corner Seniors Activity Centre in Toa Payoh, programme executive Lim Siew Eng said the elderly poor who show up for free daily lunches are asking for larger portions to take home for dinner. A typical lunch consists of rice, mixed vegetables and meat.
MP Cynthia Phua said she has been advising the elderly in her ward to rent out the rooms in their flats to generate income.
She said: 'A can of luncheon meat used to cost $1.30. Now it's $2.50. Not everyone can afford that, especially the elderly who are not working and depending on handouts.'
MPs said that they try not to give cash to residents seeking aid because they cannot ensure that the money is spent on food. They prefer to give food vouchers.
While utility, service and conservancy rebates, and Workfare payouts have helped, the MPs hope that the Government would come up with schemes which help those without income cope with the rising cost of living.
Pasir Ris-Punggol's Mr Chong said: 'The current schemes that we have, such as Workfare, help those who work. But for the elderly who are retired and sickly, we need to find new schemes for them.'
The Government has said that it will not keep prices artificially low by controlling price increases to help people cope with the rising cost of living. Its aim is to get the basics right - housing, jobs and affordable necessities.
It also tops up the wages of low-income workers through Workfare and gives various cash handouts and rebates. A total of 2.4 million Singaporeans are eligible for $650 million in GST credits and senior citizens' bonuses this year.
It is not just the low income who are feeling the pinch. Mayor for Central Singapore district, Mr Zainudin Nordin, said families living in four- and five-room flats are trying to downgrade to smaller flats because they cannot afford the cash portion of their mortgage.
He said: 'These families find that they need that few hundred dollars for other necessities now that prices have gone up. They can't afford to put aside any cash for housing.'
For housewife Norliza Maidin, 40, the rising cost of living could not have come at a worse time.
Her husband was retrenched from his warehouse supervisor job last year and now earns $1,500 - $500 less than his previous pay.
The couple have two sons -- aged five and one - and Madam Norliza's elderly mother lives with them in a four-room flat in Jurong.
Madam Norliza limits the family's electricity usage to $3 a day, chooses the cheapest fish and buys the cheapest groceries.
But she still finds herself with no savings at the end of the month. Sometimes, she has to borrow money from friends.
After being out of the workforce for five years, she is back in the job market because she wants to supplement her husband's income.
'I want to save for a rainy day. And buy better food for my children, such as salmon and not just selar,' she said.
With inflation expected to go up to 4.5 per cent next year, MPs such as Madam Phua think that the number of financial aid requests they are receiving is only the tip of the iceberg.
She said: 'I believe more will ask for financial help. This is just the beginning.' -
More coming forward to seek help
'Each week, I find myself busier and busier, staying longer and longer, because there are so many people asking for financial help.'
- MP LILY NEO (Jalan Besar GRC), who sees about 60 hard-luck cases a week at her Meet-the-People sessions
Requests getting more frequent
'They used to come once every three months. Now, some come back every couple of weeks to ask for food and utility vouchers.'
- MP ZAQY MOHAMAD (Hong Kah GRC), who said that those on financial aid schemes are showing up more often at Meet-the-People Sessions
Elderly hit hard by inflation
'A can of luncheon meat used to cost $1.30. Now it's $2.50. Not everyone can afford that, especially the elderly, who are not working and depending on handouts.'
- MP CYNTHIA PHUA (Aljunied GRC), on the situation facing the elderly
Copyright, 2007, Singapore Press Holdings Limited -
You expect people that pay themselves millions with public money to understand their plight? In this kind of animal farm society, "some" people can take millions of public money but these same people would begrudge that others get assistance from public funds...
-
How one family copes
Mother of five scrimps and saves on food, household necessities and even electricity to stretch family dollar
Sunday Times, The (Singapore)
News, Pg 11
December 2, 2007
Author: Nur Dianah Suhaimi
AFTER 15 years as a housewife, Madam Maryanti Chaman, 35, went back to work in May.
The rising price of food and the goods and services tax (GST) hike over the past year have made the family's finances very tight.
To make matters worse, her 42-year-old husband, a shipyard supervisor, saw his take-home pay reduced from $2,200 to $1,600 after his company stopped overtime work.
Madam Maryanti now works five days a week as a part-time stall assistant to supplement the family income. She earns about $600 a month. Her mother or father-in-law cares for her five children when she is at work. The family lives in a five-room flat in Marsiling.
Madam Maryanti always shops around for the cheapest groceries and household goods. She has also cut down on tidbits for her children.
The family now uses cheaper detergent, which costs about $4 for a 5kg box, compared to her previous brand, which cost $6 for a 3kg box.
Her three-year-old toddler Khalaf Hubaish drinks Dugrow milk, which costs $8.50 for a 1kg tin, instead of Friso milk, which costs $20 for an equivalent tin. He wears the cheapest diapers that Madam Maryanti can find: $12 for 35 pieces compared to $17 for other brands.
She buys fish only on Sundays, around noon, when fishmongers are clearing their stocks because the market is closed on Mondays.
'I can get 2kg of ikan selar kuning (gold-banded scad) or mackerel for just $7, instead of $6 a kilogram.' That is enough to last the family a week.
She tries to buy more chicken than fish because chicken is cheaper. The family has stopped eating out.
When she shops for groceries in Johor Baru, she takes along a calculator to make sure that she buys only things which are cheaper after the currency conversion.
When money dries up towards the end of the month, the children receive less pocket money and take a packed lunch to school.
To save on electricity charges, the family has cut down on television viewing. Electrical appliances are no longer placed on stand-by mode but switched off when not in use.
Madam Maryanti said she also makes sure that her children turn off the light when they leave a room. 'We have no choice but to do this. Everything is more expensive now.'
[email protected]
-------------------------------------------------------
Where does the money go?
THE Hazalis' combined household income: $2,200
Their monthly expenses:
Groceries: $150
Wet market items: $200
Utilities: $220
Insurance: $380
Children's pocket money and transport: $300
Mr Hazali's lunch money, transport and cigarettes: $500
Madam Maryanti's monthly savings: $100
Miscellaneous items (mobile phone bills, snacks, clothes and so on): $350
Total: $2,200
Copyright, 2007, Singapore Press Holdings Limited -
Expats here are feeling the pinch too
Sunday Times, The (Singapore)
News, Pg 11
December 2, 2007
Author: Mavis Toh & Shuli Sudderuddin
DOWNSIZING is one way of fighting soaring rents, but expatriate Diana Cloe and her husband moved downstairs instead, going from their 24th-floor condominium apartment to a similar-size unit on the fourth.
The step down came after their landlord raised the rent for their 2,900 sq ft Anderson Road flat by 40 per cent in April.
They moved down 20 floors to a flat that costs $8,200 in monthly rent - 20 per cent higher than what they were forking out.
Expats who have been complaining about rising rent are feeling vindicated by a recent global survey.
The ECA International survey showed Singapore rising 10 places to rank as the ninth-most-costly Asian city for expats.
Private home rentals have jumped by 32.2 per cent since January, compared with 14.1 per cent for the whole of last year.
Ms Cloe's American husband, a global development manager who did not want to be named, said: 'The rents are crazy. My housing allowance was $7,000 but my company was gracious enough to up it.'
Mr Ervin Scully, head of corporate leasing at Knight Frank, said soaring rents have prompted many multinationals to increase expat pay by up to 30 per cent.
Indian expat Sonya Madeira said her boss increased the pay of all 13 employees by 10 per cent after a discussion on the rising cost of living.
Ms Madeira, associate director of Eastwest Public Relations, said the rent for her 1,600 sq ft Pasir Panjang flat doubled to over $3,000. 'Prices are up but our salaries are not going up at the same pace, so it's still a bit difficult to manage,' she said.
Ms Madeira said her family might leave Singapore if rent hits $5,000.
The British and American chambers of commerce are concerned about the rise in rentals.
But Mr Terry O'Connor, president of the British chamber, said the Government's recent 'cooling measures' such as axing the deferred payment scheme has helped redress the situation. But this may not be enough to retain some expats.
Brand consultant Simon Faure-Field, 37, was hit by the doubling of both his office and home rents.
His High Street office now costs $10,000 a month but he renewed the lease as alternative locations were equally expensive.
However, when the rent for his 1,400 sq ft Bukit Timah apartment doubled to $5,000, he moved to a similar-size apartment in Pasir Ris for $3,000.
He said: 'I can live in Dubai for the same amount. But there, my company can charge up to thrice the price for our services.'
--------------------------------------------------------
Top 10 The most expensive cities in Asia:
1 Seoul
2 Tokyo
3 Yokohama
4 Kobe
5 Hong Kong
6 Taipei
7 Beijing
8 Shanghai
9 Singapore
10 Guangzhou
Copyright, 2007, Singapore Press Holdings Limited -
this is the price of a free market economy...
and having low taxes.. with absolutely no safety net...
that being said, if there was a safety net, and we raise taxes, would everyone start screaming blue murder?
also, if we put in a minimum wage regime, which will result in increased taxes, again, will everyone scream blue murder?
the world is at a crossroads now.. the price of everything going up is the start of it.. the world cannot produce as much for our consumption and scarcity of products, demands and all that will drive the price of goods up...
what can we do?
do we dare to refuse to pay the price to look after our own fellow citizens? -
....and the solution to this income gap is to ask students to write essays !
They are still in their teens and early twenties. What do they know about poverty and the plight that the poor people, the low incomes group and the jobless people are going through?
-
what is the price of closing this income gap?Originally posted by googoomuck:....and the solution to this income gap is to ask students to write essays !
They are still in their teens and early twenties. What do they know about poverty and the plight that the poor people, the low incomes group and the jobless people are going through? -
Answer is NO in long run.
-
to whose question?Originally posted by T.Ryousuke:Answer is NO in long run.
-
how does minimum wage necessary result in increased tax responsibilites?
-
the 2% went mia izzit?
-
There are ways and means to fund a proper safety at this point in time without resorting to higher GST.
It's called recalculating certain expenditure that is a luxury. -
Well, LHL has raised the GST to help the poor. Where's the money?Originally posted by the Bear:what is the price of closing this income gap?
If the foreign reserves is USD130 bn, when is the govt going to dip into it?
No more funds to dip into? Cannot ensure that the locals, especially the mid-aged one get jobs? I don't think they are sitting at home waiting to collect welfare.
I've said before, it's a shame for Asians to ask for financial assistance and it's the govt's responsiblity to ensure that citizens are gainfully employed and well compensated monetarily to have a decent living.
Do they have any option? -
Waiting for those with slanted (*hint* sgdiehard *hint*) viewpoints to defend the administration
-
Think foreign reserves may need to hit USD1000bn before they even consider dipping into it to help the poor.Originally posted by googoomuck:Well, LHL has raised the GST to help the poor. Where's the money?
If the foreign reserves is USD130 bn, when is the govt going to dip into it?
No more funds to dip into? Cannot ensure that the locals, especially the mid-aged one get jobs? I don't think they are sitting at home waiting to collect welfare.
I've said before, it's a shame for Asians to ask for financial assistance and it's the govt's responsiblity to ensure that citizens are gainfully employed and well compensated monetarily to have a decent living.
Do they have any option?
Then again, it's just a maybe.
And not before they raise their salaries by another notch or two first. -
Why bother to talk about it anymore? You think the 'our' overpaid government will bother or even lend a ear?
I'd rather sit back, let it simmer, till it all boils over into one big friggin upheaval....
.. they way I see it, it's THE only way to either get them to change, or kicked out altogether... -
bo lah.. u dun remember some other ppl got increment and bonus meh?Originally posted by BenBenDeZhu:the 2% went mia izzit? -
how come no one is complaining abuot singapore governmetn controlled newspaper huh? I thought the whiners and wankers say that our papers only publish pro PAP news? Is this pro PAP news?
-
I pity the civil service officers (admin clerks to some classes of officers) - they deserve their 13th month bonuses because they don't have anything else than their CPF to fall back on when they grow old. They are employees like other Singaporeans.Originally posted by I-like-flings(m):bo lah.. u dun remember some other ppl got increment and bonus meh?
It is not the MPs or the ministers - they got alot more money to fall back on. -
I think sooner or later, some of the ministers will be telling these poor folks to live on bread and water.
Asking them to increase assistance to the poor is so bloody hard.
I can still remember months back, one minister sarcastically asking an MP if the amount of assistance given should be based on the foodcourt prices. -
Originally posted by Gazelle:how come no one is complaining abuot singapore governmetn controlled newspaper huh? I thought the whiners and wankers say that our papers only publish pro PAP news? Is this pro PAP news?
-
Go work in Dubai, anyone?
-
What do you think?Originally posted by Gazelle:how come no one is complaining abuot singapore governmetn controlled newspaper huh? I thought the whiners and wankers say that our papers only publish pro PAP news? Is this pro PAP news? -
ya... alot of opening there now.. and they are paying crazy money...Originally posted by ^tamago^:Go work in Dubai, anyone?