Originally posted by Poh Ah Pak:many of those examples you've pointed out, free quebec, free puerto rico .. were not banned outright in their countries of origin .. but are allowed to contest freely in elections in their respective countries ... their leaders are not forced into exile
ah thanks for posting up articles on counterpunch ... I was afraid to put articles from there up ... because i have always felt that it has a leftist bias and is not credible ... but by quoting it, you seems to think that a legitimate source
allow me to post up some interesting articles from counterpunch too ... on TIBET ... ![]()
China's crackdown against Tibetan protesters ahead of the Summer Olympics in Beijing carries with it a brutal echo from the past. Scores of people, including school children are reported dead and more repression has been promised.
http://www.counterpunch.org/zirin03252008.html
At this critical moment, the Dalai Lama and Tibet need us. I ask you to join in adding your voice to those supporting the Dalai Lama, the cause of Tibetan autonomy, and an end to the violence in Tibet.
http://www.counterpunch.org/krieger03252008.html
like a few more ? .... or are you going to start on "selective interpretation" now ? .... you're just going to read what you like, and discard the rest ? ....
Originally posted by Fatum:if the US is perfect, then the chaps here wouldn't have had the chance to use Iraq as an excuse for what china is doing now, right ?
ok, if you want to avoid the cruel incidents done by US and criticize China alone, that is fine.
Now, what you meant by "what china is doing now"?
Free Hougang to become an independent state ![]()
Low TK become the President or Prime Minister
I want Geylang to be independent and I will run for PM.
I will then dismantle all the fucking brothels there.![]()
Geylang will be annexed by china one day
Free Mason!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Free Willy !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Free Jason !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Free Selamat Kastari !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
puerto rico has beautiful ladies. ![]()
Free Johore Bahru lah, with an independent JB, it would be easier for us to deal with them.
Free Singapore!
Wait long long.
"because i have always felt that it has a leftist bias and is not credible"
So says the hippie who cries "FREE TIBET".
many stupid people around
There are still some people who say 'Chinese Opression' or 'Sending/ flooding Han Chinese into Tibet'.
I ask something....
What is this so-called Chinese opression...?
Do u know in China, ethnic minorities actually enjoy some positive priviledges compared to majority Han Chinese..?
For instance 1 child policy is not applied to them.
Welfare payment, and assistance is easier for them.
I wonder what is this so-called 'Chinese opression' kept being said by some people. What is this Chinese Opression..? Have u been to Tibet?
My sister just 1 year ago or so, visited Tibet together with her husband, my brother in law.
Tibet is a normal place, a tourist place. Local Tibetans are living there as usual, working, going to school, and interacting with tourists. Everything is normal. Just very common.
'Chinese Opression' ?
Dont make a joke please.
Not only are they treated with special priviledge, Chinese government has poured alot of money to build Tibet and improve its economy and well-being of the people.
One particular special example is the train, the highest train that cost alot of money to build, to improve the infrastucture because Tibet is an isolated interior, a poor place. Hopefully it can bring positive impact for Tibet.
If you look at this....how can you say....this is called 'Chinese Opression' ?
I wonder why some people are so Anti-China. Please before you say 'Free Tibet', first and foremost free your own mind first from prejudice and negativity.
And another thing...I cant believe some people actually say 'China send Han Chinese to swamp Tibet' etc.
Why cant people from Shanghai go to Tibet to open a restaurant..? China is one country, everyone can go to everywhere.
Those are common people, people who try to make a living, opening up restaurants, shops, hotels, and so on. After all, Tibet is a tourist place.
What is so unnatural about this..?
Do you think they are told by the government to open up businesses and move there..?
In Hawaii, white people go to there to settle and to open hotels and other businesses. In Bali, non-Balinese go there in large numbers to do business there too.
What is the problem with people moving from one province to another province..?
I cant believe the extreme prejudice against China. Before u indulge in such thoughts, at least stop urself and ask urself, why are you so anti-China. What is there in your mind..? It cant be right. China is just a country, a society, a people. It is not any worse or any more evil than the other nations in the world. Everyone is the same. I hope u can understand this. Do not indulge in stereotyping and narrow-minded prejudice.
Meat Pao.
And sgForums should be freed from this nonsense
And sgForums should be freed from this nonsense
Very true.
Singapore can't even free itself from PAP rule.
That is the real problem for us, not get involved in some anti-China political game.
Originally posted by idiotbutcherer:
The majority of the natives are quite happy with the current state they are in. So, there are also opponents against the sovereignty movement.
Originally posted by Meat Pao:There are still some people who say 'Chinese Opression' or 'Sending/ flooding Han Chinese into Tibet'.
I ask something....
What is this so-called Chinese opression...?
Do u know in China, ethnic minorities actually enjoy some positive priviledges compared to majority Han Chinese..?
For instance 1 child policy is not applied to them.
Welfare payment, and assistance is easier for them.
I wonder what is this so-called 'Chinese opression' kept being said by some people. What is this Chinese Opression..? Have u been to Tibet?
My sister just 1 year ago or so, visited Tibet together with her husband, my brother in law.
Tibet is a normal place, a tourist place. Local Tibetans are living there as usual, working, going to school, and interacting with tourists. Everything is normal. Just very common.
'Chinese Opression' ?
Dont make a joke please.
Not only are they treated with special priviledge, Chinese government has poured alot of money to build Tibet and improve its economy and well-being of the people.
One particular special example is the train, the highest train that cost alot of money to build, to improve the infrastucture because Tibet is an isolated interior, a poor place. Hopefully it can bring positive impact for Tibet.
If you look at this....how can you say....this is called 'Chinese Opression' ?
I wonder why some people are so Anti-China. Please before you say 'Free Tibet', first and foremost free your own mind first from prejudice and negativity.
And another thing...I cant believe some people actually say 'China send Han Chinese to swamp Tibet' etc.
Why cant people from Shanghai go to Tibet to open a restaurant..? China is one country, everyone can go to everywhere.
Those are common people, people who try to make a living, opening up restaurants, shops, hotels, and so on. After all, Tibet is a tourist place.
What is so unnatural about this..?
Do you think they are told by the government to open up businesses and move there..?
In Hawaii, white people go to there to settle and to open hotels and other businesses. In Bali, non-Balinese go there in large numbers to do business there too.
What is the problem with people moving from one province to another province..?
I cant believe the extreme prejudice against China. Before u indulge in such thoughts, at least stop urself and ask urself, why are you so anti-China. What is there in your mind..? It cant be right. China is just a country, a society, a people. It is not any worse or any more evil than the other nations in the world. Everyone is the same. I hope u can understand this. Do not indulge in stereotyping and narrow-minded prejudice.
Meat Pao.
a nicely worded piece meat pao .... and i hear your points, but let's put things into another perspective now shall we ....
yes, minorities do enjoy things like the two child policies ... unfortunately, tibetans in no way enjoy equal rights as other citizens of china ... this is from a tibetan in lhasa mind you, not from me ... for example ... they are not allowed to travel freely to other places, unlike the han chinese. You see large numbers of chinese in singapore, they are able to come here for work and play freely, but the movement of tibetans outside of the country is strictly controlled, and subjected to goverment approval ... and they are banned from going to india, presumably because their spritual leader, the dalai lama is there, overseas travel is strictly restricted as well, ... their temples of worship that exist in tibet today are also controlled, vetted, and approved by the chinese authorities, those that do not conform (I suppose, because of their links to the "dalai lama clique"?) are already closed down. What you see, even as a tourist, is very different from that the native tibetans feel about it ...
oh, I don't image that ALL tibetans would be unhappy about chinese rule ... after all, materialism is a very powerful lure ... but why are so many tibetans willing to put their lives on the line, to face PLA bullets, if they were so happy and satisfied under chinese rule ? ... maybe because we're too caught up with the material side of things, and find it hard to comprehend why anyone would want to agitate for freedom and independence if they had it so good right ? ... perhaps it'd be like the PAP asking, "I give you prosperity, I give you development, what more to you want" to our friend Poh Ah Pak here, right ? perhaps he'd like to answer that question. after all, outside tourists do like to think we have it pretty good too ..... so don't you suppose there are undercurrents that we do not easily see as outsiders, that drive the tibetans thus, just like in Singapore ? ... or do you really believe in the story that a few ang mohs are behind all this ? ... the dalai lama ? .......... isn't it like justdoit77 stating that the african countries are better off being colonies of the UK today, because they are such basket cases as independant countries today ?.. can you see the sanctimonity of such line of thought ? ... but maybe it's because we are all Chinese, and even here in Singapore, we are not a minority, and that makes it difficult for us to see things from another perspective .....
in any case, my friend's tibetan friend has dropped out of sight for a whole week now ... nothing's been heard from him since last week ... hopefully, it's nothing more serious but the current ban on internet access there after the riots .... but I'm keeping my fingers crossed for the chap ... after all, if there's nothing to hide, if there are no crackdowns on the streets, if there's no skeletons in the closets, if people are happy there, if there are no tibetans killed, there really isn't any reason to ban internet access to the outside world right ? ... or he cannot be allowed to tell his story, to voice his discontent ? ...
remember that in Singapore, we can have threads right here in speaker's corner with titles like "when is lee Kuan Yew going to die"... and here we are calmly voicing greviences against our goverment .... people over there, do not have such a privilege ....
Originally posted by Fatum:.......... isn't it like justdoit77 stating that the african countries are better off being colonies of the UK today, because they are such basket cases as independant countries today ?
I never say this statement before. I hope this is a mistake from you instead of a deliberate action, don't make everyone here think that you are another "CNN".
I have met so many people who come from Tibet, none of them complaint having restriction when travelling overseas.
Originally posted by justdoit77:I never say this statement before. I hope this is a mistake from you instead of a deliberate action, don't make everyone here think that you are another "CNN".
I have met so many people who come from Tibet, none of them complaint having restriction when travelling overseas.
Yes indeed you are right, did I quoted from the wrong person, it was ray245 who said that instead, not you. I apologize to you for this unreservedly.
The restriction of travel on the tibetans is true, they are indeed tightly vetted before they can get travel documents overseas ... while travel to india faces an outright ban, cos India is where the "dalai lama" clique is I suppose ...
Originally posted by monoslayer:puerto rico has beautiful ladies.
Really would they want me? ![]()
Here's another
FREE BIES !!!!
Originally posted by Fatum:Yes indeed you are right, did I quoted from the wrong person, it was ray245 who said that instead, not you. I apologize to you for this unreservedly.
No problem.
I hope after so many comments from different forummers, you will have a clearer and neutral stance on the Tibet issues.
Originally posted by justdoit77:No problem.
I hope after so many comments from different forummers, you will have a clearer and neutral stance on the Tibet issues.
the thought is mutual as well ..... ![]()
of course ... we are lucky here where we are that a diversity of views is allowed ... not everyone has that luxury where they come from, it's important to remember that ...
we are lucky here where we are that a diversity of views is allowed
Not in mainstream propaganda media.
Originally posted by Poh Ah Pak:we are lucky here where we are that a diversity of views is allowed
Not in mainstream propaganda media.
in counterpunch.org perhaps ? .... ![]()
in counterpunch.org perhaps ?
???
Originally posted by Fatum:the thought is mutual as well .....
of course ... we are lucky here where we are that a diversity of views is allowed ... not everyone has that luxury where they come from, it's important to remember that ...
Diversity of views should be allowed, but not violence and riots that harms people's lives and property.
When one go to any nearby MRT, put a banner of "Independence of Jurong Island", the police may not catch you immediately. But if the person start attacking the people nearby or try to blast the Yishun MRT. The police will come very quickly.