Is my HDB flat is my property
-
judge not less you be judge.
i do not impose my view on anybody. A newbie here also have the right to make comment. Did I insult anyone here? This is a forum where people say what they like. my apologies if what i post upset you.
-
Originally posted by TemplarKnight:
judge not less you be judge.
i do not impose my view on anybody. A newbie here also have the right to make comment. Did I insult anyone here? This is a forum where people say what they like. my apologies if what i post upset you.
ya lor, very good to say whatever you want and not be responsible for what you said.judge not less you be judge.- ha ha ha ha, hypocritical statement you made.
-
say whatever you want. I do not judge.
-
Originally posted by TemplarKnight:
say whatever you want. I do not judge.
ha ha ha ha, very funny. -
HDB flats property tax range from few bucks to ten plus---per month.
-
try getting the ghamen to waive loh.......... property aso not belong to peasants here. Those are HDB ones...
-
Err.. not happy with the current situation, just sell the HDB and rent?
Then let the "buyer" of the HDB pay the property tax?
-
whichever way peasant still stand to lose. u dont pay tax but pay for rental same... more jialak
-
Hmm... but in life there is nothing free right? If I want a place to live, I have to either own it or rent it from someone right?
-
Originally posted by eagle:
This is an overly simplistic view.
You need to take into account average salaries/wages (in their currencies as well). However, this is still simplistic because other factors like GST, petrol tax, average price of food, etc etc, all comes into account.
Ultimately, as pointed out by M13, it's where the money went to that counts the most.
of course it is, so is kpkb about property tax alone. that's why I said we cannot look at one tax item in islolation and not the whole tax system.
m13 said the higher taxes in Singapore collected go to pay for the multi million dollars salaries of the ministers, blah blah blah....is it not simplistic?
when taking into account of the average salaries/wages plus tax, you also have to consider how much you pay in each place for a simple meal, then you consider the space you have in a city vs that in the country side, then again ... can we ever find a way to compare the costs and benefits of living in any two different places?
There will always be pros and cons, and not everybody is born with silver spoon, look more at the positive sides and you will be happier. Those losers who find fault will never be happy.
A better comparison would be to find out how much you have to pay and what property tax and other taxes you have to pay to live in a 5 rooms apartment of about 1000sq. in Singapore, London, Sydney and Vancouver/Toronto, or LA?
-
Originally posted by sgdiehard:
of course it is, so is kpkb about property tax alone. that's why I said we cannot look at one tax item in islolation and not the whole tax system.
m13 said the higher taxes in Singapore collected go to pay for the multi million dollars salaries of the ministers, blah blah blah....is it not simplistic?
when taking into account of the average salaries/wages plus tax, you also have to consider how much you pay in each place for a simple meal, then you consider the space you have in a city vs that in the country side, then again ... can we ever find a way to compare the costs and benefits of living in any two different places?
There will always be pros and cons, and not everybody is born with silver spoon, look more at the positive sides and you will be happier. Those losers who find fault will never be happy.
A better comparison would be to find out how much you have to pay and what property tax and other taxes you have to pay to live in a 5 rooms apartment of about 1000sq. in Singapore, London, Sydney and Vancouver/Toronto, or LA?
I thought page 2 last post, you were the one talking about property tax in UK, Australia and Canada? I see! After you found out about your folly, you sidetrack into something else, now you accused me of comparing different systems.
My replies to you were all about property taxes, the post which you have initiated.
-
Originally posted by maurizio13:
I thought page 2 last post, you were the one talking about property tax in UK, Australia and Canada? I see! After you found out about your folly, you sidetrack into something else, now you accused me of comparing different systems.
My replies to you were all about property taxes, the post which you have initiated.
Anyway, i do envy him for the way he sidetracked, got future..
-
Originally posted by angel7030:
Anyway, i do envy him for the way he sidetracked, got future..
Got potential to be PAP MP.
-
Originally posted by angel7030:
Anyway, i do envy him for the way he sidetracked, got future..
If others do the same, he will complain complain complain, jump jump jump already. He practises double standard.
-
Originally posted by maurizio13:
Got potential to be PAP MP.
hey, may be he is IB.
-
Originally posted by Fantagf:
If others do the same, he will complain complain complain, jump jump jump already. He practises double standard.
can practise double standard not easy ok, i learned for years since primary school to learn it. -
Originally posted by angel7030:
Anyway, i do envy him for the way he sidetracked, got future..
haha...those who focus on despot got no future, those who got one track mind, got no future, those who only look at the negative sides also got no future, those who kia si loh one also got no future.but I need to learn from you, live an earthly life, but feel like an angel. hahahaha...
-
Originally posted by TemplarKnight:
have have.. ghamen own state land.......
yeah it true even a small land size of half football field they put a sign state land and blah blah blah arrrr -
Originally posted by ArtBoon:
Err.. not happy with the current situation, just sell the HDB and rent?
Then let the "buyer" of the HDB pay the property tax?
It easy to say sell and rent, do u know the law on renting of flat? My CPF who earn it, Why i have to earn hard to top up my cpf ever month when i don't use it, They should scrap this ideal of property tax as HBD flat is lease for some period also help alot of citizens -
Originally posted by lionnoisy:
HDB flats property tax range from few bucks to ten plus---per month.
Yeah it true what u say, If 1 years few hundred dollar, save me if i don't have to pay and save garmen don't have to give me NSS, ERS and any other share arr -
Originally posted by sgdiehard:
of course it is, so is kpkb about property tax alone. that's why I said we cannot look at one tax item in islolation and not the whole tax system.
m13 said the higher taxes in Singapore collected go to pay for the multi million dollars salaries of the ministers, blah blah blah....is it not simplistic?
when taking into account of the average salaries/wages plus tax, you also have to consider how much you pay in each place for a simple meal, then you consider the space you have in a city vs that in the country side, then again ... can we ever find a way to compare the costs and benefits of living in any two different places?
There will always be pros and cons, and not everybody is born with silver spoon, look more at the positive sides and you will be happier. Those losers who find fault will never be happy.
A better comparison would be to find out how much you have to pay and what property tax and other taxes you have to pay to live in a 5 rooms apartment of about 1000sq. in Singapore, London, Sydney and Vancouver/Toronto, or LA?
Why nobody compare malaysia or indonesia property tax ? Are our standard of living as same as US, Canada, London ? do they have HDB flat?
-
Err... I don't understand what u are trying to say.
No law says I cannot sell my flat and then rent from others...
Yes, it is your choice to use your CPF to buy a property.
I can understand the idea that since the public is lessee of HDB flat, so they should not pay tax as they are not owner. But from what I read here, many other countries are doing it. We are just practising a legacy law.
On the other hand, if government tweaks this legacy law and losses the tax revenue from HDB dwellers, they can always find another method, eg get town councils to increase fee and then charge the town councils through some other fee??
It easy to say sell and rent, do u know the law on renting of flat? My CPF who earn it, Why i have to earn hard to top up my cpf ever month when i don't use it, They should scrap this ideal of property tax as HBD flat is lease for some period also help alot of citizens -
Originally posted by maurizio13:
Got potential to be PAP MP.
As long fight for the people ok arr not only take pay and tight lip -
Originally posted by sgdiehard:
hehehe... australian government not greedy huh, why collect income tax up to 45%? almost half of I can earn. The more I earn the more I got taxed, not punitive tax mei?don't waste time here.
Well, Singapore has no welfare system, only pay and pay.
-
Originally posted by rockfire:
Why nobody compare malaysia or indonesia property tax ? Are our standard of living as same as US, Canada, London ? do they have HDB flat?
you are welcome to compare malaysia or indonesia with Singapore, I won't cause I won't want to own any property there. It is easy and no headache to rent a nice place there.