China students lash out S'pore's been good to you
By Dawn Chia
THIS China student wants to tell Singapore's youth to wake up, stop being so proud and stop feeding on pigswill.
And other China students studying in Singapore are apparently nodding in agreement, at least on a website forum.
'Singaporeans' brains are fed with pigswill, fat, have no intelligence, feel complacent even though they've only accomplished something small,' wrote this China student. Calling one of his Singaporean project mates 'stupid', he claimed that he could finish in a day what took that student four weeks to complete.
Is this merely teenage ranting?
Not really. The comment comes from an 18-year-old from China studying at a local polytechnic on a tuition fee grant for foreign students. He left these scathing remarks on a public forum on the sgchinese.com website.
He was one of 13 forum members who chided Singaporeans for forgetting their roots.
Others were less polite.
SLAMMING
SINGAPORE One said: '...The money for my school fees is given by their Government, and I'll be gone after I complete my studies.'
Another wrote: 'I really don't like Singapore and I really don't want to stay. No-one asked the Singapore Government to be so cheap, to pay our school fees for us to stay.
'...Rest assured that we will not stay after we complete our studies. I will not return to Singapore even if you ask me to.'
The New Paper on Sunday got in touch with the writer of the 'pigswill' posting and found him quick to stand by his views.
And he did not hesitate to lay out his demands.
No names, no pictures, and no face-to-face interviews, he specified.
He preferred to hide behind his user name on the forum - diablo3434 - and only consented to speak to us over the phone.
diablo3434 is a nickname he picked out of his love for the computer game, Diablo.
The second-year electronics student said that at first he did not have a bad impression of Singaporeans.
He has been in Singapore for two years, and recalled the first few months of his life as filled with many happy memories.
He said in Mandarin: 'When I had problems, Singaporeans were very helpful, and I liked them.
'But as I got to know them, I discovered a side of them that I didn't like.
'They look down on China and its people for no reason and I think that makes them very narrow-minded and misinformed.'
The outspoken teenager has no regrets at lashing out at his project-mate and Singaporeans on the Mar 7 Internet posting.
He said, with a hint of arrogance in his tone: 'I was frustrated when I wrote it - my project mate wasn't contributing, and was causing a delay in our group's progress.
'He was lazy and spent his time playing computer games.
'Sometimes I get angry and will say nasty things on the spur of the moment. I'm only human, like everyone else.'
He visits this particular website daily, or once a week, depending on his workload.
He doesn't think that it was wrong of him to have expressed his views - negative and blistering as they were.
The only son of two teachers, his monthly expenses are about $600 - $300 for his own expenditure and another $300 for rent.
He gets his pocket money from his parents, he said.
He lives in the East.
His criticism of Singapore and its youth have angered some Singaporean students and his classmates.
But the China student retorted: 'It's on the Internet, and people say all sorts of things on the Net.
'Even though I'm on a Singapore Government scholarship, I'm entitled to an opinion of my own.
'This is not defamatory.
'Moreover, Singaporeans hardly go to that website. It's mostly China students, and we share our views there.'
He claimed that it was the first time he had criticised Singaporeans so strongly.
The teenager, who is from the north-east region of China, heard about this forum from some friends in February.
The date accompanying this particular posting showed that he had registered his membership on Feb 20.
He was looking for a second-hand piano and went to the website to see if there was one for sale.
He found more than what he was looking for.
Besides being connected to some 40,000 members - mostly China students in Singapore - he could freely air his views on topics he is passionate about.
HELPING CHINA STUDENTS
He said he liked helping fellow China students who, like him, had faced problems such as finding their way around, or what to do if they lose their student pass.
IT programmer Patrick Li, a China national, set up the website in June 2001 to help China students cope with problems.
A few friends are helping him manage the website.
Mr Li, 26, estimates that at least 60 per cent of the 40,000 members are students from China studying in Singapore.
The rest are from Indonesia, Malaysia, Canada and even the US.
As much as the site allows members to voice their opinions freely, the webmaster stresses that strict rules apply.
He explained: 'We're very strict about monitoring content. There are about 80 moderators, including myself, who help monitor the forums. Messages which indulge in personal attacks, criticisms of any Government, or selling illegal stuff, will be taken down immediately.'
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Don't forget your roots
THE China teenager isn't the only one with strong views on Singaporeans.
His was the fifth response to a posting started by a forum member called Volts.
At least 95 responses were posted under the topic of Singaporeans.
Volts, who has been in Singapore for five years, criticised Singaporeans for thinking the world of themselves. He also wrote about what he felt as a scholarship student.
'When the teachers see me, they look as if I owe them something, like they are our providers and we should be grateful and slog for them willingly.'
Sean21 chided Singaporeans for forgetting that their ancestors came from the Fujian and Guangdong provinces, and also for being culturally barren.
'The TV programmes are boring and there are errors in the newspapers and magazines! Apart from 'good food', it's 'keeping a mistress', even a tree being struck by lightning can make the headlines in a newspaper...!'
The 35th posting said curtly: 'It doesn't matter to me. After all, the money for my school fees is given by their Government, and I'll be gone after I complete my studies.'
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
You are in my country, respect it please
UNGRATEFUL. Out of line. Uncalled for.
These are some of the responses to the China teenager's words from his Singaporean classmates.
The question they raised: Shouldn't he be more respectful of Singaporeans since he's on a tuition grant sponsored by the Singapore Government?
They spoke on the condition of anonymity as they did not want to strain their relationship with China students.
Ben, for instance, claims he couldn't sleep after he heard about the scathing Internet posting from his girlfriend on Apr 4.
He said: 'I don't really like the fast pace in Singapore but I'm still a Singaporean, and deep down, I love my country. It really bothered me and I decided to have a good talk with him about it.'
But it was in vain.
He recalled that even though the teenager agreed that he did not hate all Singaporeans, he stood by his opinion.
Ben said: 'He said it was only natural for him to have his own opinion, which I agree. But I told him he should think more before putting it into words as they could have serious repercussions.'
For Ben, the repercussions are already apparent.
The posting, and his confronting the teenager, have created a rift between him and his China-born girlfriend of more than a year.
She was unhappy that he had taken the matter so seriously.
But Ben is unwilling to back down.
He said: 'She felt that I should let it go, but I can't, and won't. I asked if she would be upset if I said such things about her country and people, and she got angry with me.
'We did not speak for four days after that.'
Another classmate also felt the remarks were unwarranted and unfounded.
The 18-year-old said: 'He's only lived here for a short while, and can't have seen much of Singapore or our way of living.
'What he's seen is only a small part, so how much does he really know?
'It doesn't seem very fair for him to be making these accusations.'
Some believe that this is an isolated case, saying that there are bound to be 'some bad apples in every basket'.
One student said that even if the teenager did not like Singapore, he should not make such an all-embracing statement, condemning its people.
He felt the posting began as a personal attack on one person, but got out of hand and became an attack on all Singaporeans.
He said: 'You don't have to like everything, but you must respect people and things you disagree with.
'Moreover, you have to respect the authorities and people who are making your tuition grant possible.'
Ben said that the more he read, the more incensed he got.
'I never expected these students to be so undiscerning, and unappreciative of what our Government has done for them,' he said grimly.
hmm... i do not particularly shun or become exceptionally nasty to my PRC frens in uni. In fact if that really happens, it is not becos they are from China that i treat them differently. It is jus that some of them behave in an intolerable manner, as if they are the elites in school. In fact, I do have a few close PRC frens and they can be fun-loving and nice to hang out with too.Originally posted by stupidissmart:However I do find some of their points true. Singaporean generally r not friendly to PRC people... In fact if some singaporean r extra friendly to china people, they seems to be "despised" by singaporean themselves... I find this particularly true for the ladies hereThey seems to be particularly... not nasty... but unfriendly towards people from china. Why huh ?
Is it because they feel china women r like wu ya ?
You fail to look beyond the exterior, you always think its them who shun you and congregate in their own groups. But think about this, have any of you actually "welcomed them" into your circles? I seriously doubt it for most of you anyway. Most people are what they are because of what they choose to be, and choice is also influenced by other choices. E.g. I choose to be friendly to people here, but if they do not choose to reciprocrate with me, what choice do i have?Originally posted by frank_person:To be frank, towards these so-called "china ppl" that ppl term them as, I do admit they may be better than us in certain aspects, especially academically, becos they have put in much much more effort than we do in their studies. But, I wish to put forth my view, that many of them do not have a "life". In the sense that they enclose themselves in their own world and think that we are deliberately isolating them or wat.... Many of them do not know what leisure is, and some of them seek solace in computer games and call that their "lives".
So wat if they develop IQ but not EQ right?
Haha! You have answered that question. The fact that these PRC scholars are brought in by the government on special packages because they have good grades is precisely what makes these PRC people different. And local people in Singapore shun things that are different from the norm, that's basis one for discrimination. I have seen it, whenever a PRC dude comes to join a local clique, they all look/regard him differently with an air of "wtf are you doing here? GO hang with your own PRC people", so how can we... no.. how can YOU PEOPLE deny that you don't discriminate against them.Originally posted by Shotgun:Some of these Chinese students claim that we descriminate against them. What descrimination could you possible face when the Government of Singapore has already provided u with student grants similar to that of a Singapore-citizen?
huh?Originally posted by PachelbeL_20:I hate them !!!! if u think singaporeans are kiasu , they are extra ultra kiasu. Smell bad, nv bath properly, think they are still living in villages. Nv bother to comb their hair and dress so poorly tt i always laff at watever fashion sense they hav.... if there is any in the 1st place. There is this day tt i notice the same guy wearin the same attire for 2 days ..... wat u think.... Also tok veri loudly in their heavily accented tongue, think their tongues were tied up by their parents when they were young...
Y are we still allowin them here? They are god-damn clever.....
well your point is valid..but not to the extend of carrying their balls n licking their nuts when they start to spit u on the face..Originally posted by Blueray:S'pore is not a welfare state. S'pore is not going to sponsor any mainland students for free. So don't be naive. There are always strings attached behind financial aids. One of the most obvious reasons is to open doors into the mainland market for local products and services. For a country without natural resources, exporting goods and services are the only few ways for survival. It is estimated that in the next 15 years, there will be over 100 million mainland tourists traveling aboard annually. I have a friend who just came back from France. He told me that in Paris the locals working in branded shops are putting more emphasize in learning Mandarin bcos mainland tourists are one of the biggest spenders in Europe. I am sure we all know S'pore is very dependant on tourism. Therefore for Singaporeans who get so upset with mainland Chinese, we better start make good on the relationship with China and its people because our livelihood and future depends on it.