Commando knife vs bannet knife.
-
which 1 will be more effective during close combat, if both are used in the hand?
and why are commandos issued special knife?
-
I think the word is BAYONET.
-
no. it's Stiletto.Originally posted by Chin Eng:I think the word is BAYONET.
-
i think he's tryin' to say that bayonet was not written correctly on the topic.
in any case the CDO stilleto (or however you call it) is sharp on both sides. very useful for cutting throats. This is in line with the CDOs use of sneaking up from the enemies' behind and killing them 'assasin' style.
the bayonet is mainly used for stabbing. hahaha... reminds me of BCCT -
Is there still bayonet fighting ?
I thought the new SAR21 could not accomodate a bayonet. -
they say this one is very lethal to the throat.
-
You think they so good to issue you the stiletto ar . The only time you will get to hold it is during red beret presentation. If wan buy to keep for souvenir hafta get from Shears close to 100 bucks
-
Because of its shape,length and weight (heavy at the front)this one is deadly and multipurpose.From the Ghurkas we all came to know it as the Kukri but even some ethnic people like the padang in Sumatra use it under a different name.The origin of this blade can be traced back to ancient Greece.Originally posted by R3SsH|n:they say this one is very lethal to the throat. -
Originally posted by sir sickolot II:
till today I could never say BCCT but BTCC instead
i think he's tryin' to say that bayonet was not written correctly on the topic.
in any case the CDO stilleto (or however you call it) is sharp on both sides. very useful for cutting throats. This is in line with the CDOs use of sneaking up from the enemies' behind and killing them 'assasin' style.
the bayonet is mainly used for stabbing. hahaha... reminds me of BCCT
.I remember that camp is really a Chobolan camp in the SAF so its Bo Taichi Cho (BTCC) camp 
-
Originally posted by KoolKool:Is there still bayonet fighting ?
I thought the new SAR21 could not accomodate a bayonet. SAR21 can or cannot accomodate bayonet is irrelevant I think... it is way too short, not to mention.... stupid looking. -
guard_01,
my background: Jeet Kune Do; situational experience: kena encounters 4 times (I think my wallet too big); Injuries: Fracture of the little finger (me) other parties (2 broken arms, 1 broken leg, 1 concussion)
I have both a stiletto and a normal full tang knife, plus many others.
I find that the stiletto is pretty long, and it is hard to stab. I prefer slicing and thrusting with it. (Hold it like kitchen knife)
The full tang knife I prefer to hold it SEAL style, and stab.
If you ask me to fight againt a trained knife fighter I would choose the full tang knife rather than the stiletto, because the stiletto does not have the versatality of blocking. The stiletto is also prone to ge caught in the grooves of a full tang knife (not applicable to bayonet)
But just curious... why ask this kind of question? -
bayonet is use when u are so damn close to the enemy when u have no bullets.. and CDO knife used to kill ppl silently... but bayonet kinda no use.. Cuz when the enemy is damn close to u,u will noe it time to call in help to get u out already..
-
Originally posted by gaoxingdcf:
ok. imagine ur whole division is annihilated, only left u n one last enemy standing with no more ammo.
bayonet is use when u are so damn close to the enemy when u have no bullets.. and CDO knife used to kill ppl silently... but bayonet kinda no use.. Cuz when the enemy is damn close to u,u will noe it time to call in help to get u out already.. -
Both can go home and sleep lah!Originally posted by monoslayer:ok. imagine ur whole division is annihilated, only left u n one last enemy standing with no more ammo. -
Yah, shake hand and call it a day. "Win-win" situation envisioned by our leaders.Originally posted by Short Ninja:Both can go home and sleep lah! -
u all think our bayonets can kill? it is not even sharp enought to cut apple.
-
try thrusting the bayonet into the apple instead.Originally posted by Gordonator:u all think our bayonets can kill? it is not even sharp enought to cut apple. -
Its not for killing its for making a person toOriginally posted by Gordonator:u all think our bayonets can kill? it is not even sharp enought to cut apple. cry out Aduhh Sakittttttttttttt!!! -
Lol... my friend tell me this story.. dunno whether true or he just joking...Originally posted by Gordonator:u all think our bayonets can kill? it is not even sharp enought to cut apple.
He said in JCC (Or some jungle course) they don't use the bayonet to kill the animals, but use the rifle (M16) butt to wack the animal instead -
Btw TS, I suggest you start your own forum on Martial arts/street defence or something like that; that way you can control the content of your own forum.
Your posts "not here not there" one.. not really got anything to do with SAF, I checked some other forums and I can't find any forum that fits your post as well, and I don't think the people in the SAF forum can really answer your questions.. They have experience with firearms but unarmed combat I think the most they know is ACCT. -
there is a martial art forum my friend though not really activeOriginally posted by chanjyj:Btw TS, I suggest you start your own forum on Martial arts/street defence or something like that; that way you can control the content of your own forum.
Your posts "not here not there" one.. not really got anything to do with SAF, I checked some other forums and I can't find any forum that fits your post as well, and I don't think the people in the SAF forum can really answer your questions.. They have experience with firearms but unarmed combat I think the most they know is ACCT. -
ok.. Noted.Originally posted by NewAge:there is a martial art forum my friend though not really active -
Thx for the replies guys....
will be taking note of the above...
(i never actually learned to knock out people by the way) -
Eh...
SAF bayonet use for prodding mines nia...
Other than that... Maybe use for scratching -
uhh!Originally posted by DarthBart:Eh...
SAF bayonet use for prodding mines nia...
Other than that... Maybe use for scratching
I thought only for parades and guard duty.