So each person can find their own truth in Buddhism. Buddha gives you some guidelines and ask to discover it for yourself. But it seems the nature of many people not to be able to trust their own experiences. They want certainty. When they do not find the evidence for something, they cannot simply say I do not know. It makes him feel unstable. So they cling on to "truths" based on other's experience. So you hold on to truths that Jesus and Buddha or the Holy Book teaches even when it does not jell with your own experience.Although Buddhism definitely helps in our living, in ethical ways, and also seeking tranquility and bliss, liberatedness, I have not yet have any real attainment or insights. But with Awareness of our living, emotions, we do not become afflicted or deluded, that is how we gain in wisdom. Buddhadharma is definitely practical in life and if one practises it will bring results. One should never believe in Buddhism for the sake of believing, but actually practise what the Buddha taught. If one only believes, and never actually utilize what the Buddha taught, then the belief is of little use. I remember Thusness once asked me about my faith.
It takes someone of the stature of Einstein to understand that Buddha does not expect his disciples to apply his teachings in a dogmatic manner. Buddha expects his disciples to discover the truths for themselves.
I would suggest that you tell me what your experiences are that makes you hold on to beliefs that should be in the realm of "maybe" "interesting" "I do not know" instead of holding on to them in a dogmatic manner when there are no evidence for them based on your own experience.
If you have experienced it, then maybe you can tell me about it and I see if I experience the same and if I do, we are then in agreement. Otherwise, we continue to cling on to doubt and continue to search or simply rest in the unknown and base all our decisions in life on reality, the known, the ethical if you want to and the logical.If so far all you have done is only reading, reasoning, then I am afraid no matter how enlightened or experienced (i am not - just an example) i am, you will never be in agreement with me.
Originally posted by casino_king:You have to admit that there are many unknown in this world that science has yet to explain and discover. Im not suggesting you should blindly follow or even accept what people in this forum has said. You should explore and uncover buddhism teachings; find something you can relate to spiritually. Faith comes naturally when you can relate to it spirtually.
When I asked you to find out what dogma is, you just refuse don't you? If like you say, Buddha asked you not to accept his teaching dogmatically, he meant that you must relate to it based on your own experience.
As far as my experience tells me and by looking at reality, there is simply no evidence of past lives and rebirth. Neither has your experience. [b]Without past lives and rebirth, then Karma is out too. You said that you are not at a certain level to be able to discern these things. When you fail to experience it or obtain conclusive evidence of it for yourself, you use dogma, that is, Buddha's teachings and all those references to the websites. Buddha himself tells you not to do that didn't he? He asked you to find out for yourself, to experience it yourself isn't it?
That is what Einstein find so interesting about Buddhism. That and the fact the there is no personal God.
So each person can find their own truth in Buddhism. Buddha gives you some guidelines and ask to discover it for yourself. But it seems the nature of many people not to be able to trust their own experiences. They want certainty. When they do not find the evidence for something, they cannot simply say I do not know. It makes him feel unstable. So they cling on to "truths" based on other's experience. So you hold on to truths that Jesus and Buddha or the Holy Book teaches even when it does not jell with your own experience.
It takes someone of the stature of Einstein to understand that Buddha does not expect his disciples to apply his teachings in a dogmatic manner. Buddha expects his disciples to discover the truths for themselves.
I would suggest that you tell me what your experiences are that makes you hold on to beliefs that should be in the realm of "maybe" "interesting" "I do not know" instead of holding on to them in a dogmatic manner when there are no evidence for them based on your own experience.
If you have experienced it, then maybe you can tell me about it and I see if I experience the same and if I do, we are then in agreement. Otherwise, we continue to cling on to doubt and continue to search or simply rest in the unknown and base all our decisions in life on reality, the known, the ethical if you want to and the logical.[/b]
Relax my fren... these pple just nt awaken yetOriginally posted by marcteng:For people who criticises, they failed to see their faults unfortunately.
Easy to see other faults, but one's fault is indeed hard to see.
They are their worst enemies, cutting off their nose to spite their faces, its a bit like biting the hand that feeds you.
They are playing with fire, but they didnt realise they are burning their own houses. The dhamma which is like in heaven, those fools who criticise, thought by spitting at the heaven, reckon the spit will soil the heaven, but the spit comes back and soiled oneself.
Lol, not only them, we also unawakened yet.Originally posted by neutral_onliner:Relax my fren... these pple just nt awaken yet![]()
Originally posted by paperflower:This makes so much sense and is so useful for everyday living right? Buddhism can be very useful if not for all the fantastic beliefs that goes with it.
the Buddha once told the layman Dighajanu that there are 4 things conducive to happiness in this world:
to be skilled,
to be efficient,
to be energetic,
to be earnest and learned...
in whatever profession one has; to conscientiously protect one's income and family's mean of support; to have virtuous, trustworthy and faithful friends and spiritual aspirations; to be content and to live within one's means.
this advice aptly demontrates the [b]Buddha's commonsense approach as well as his capacity to relate to laymen.
[/b]
what fantastic beliefs? Elaborate more... plsOriginally posted by casino_king:This makes so much sense and is so useful for everyday living right? Buddhism can be very useful if not for all the fantastic beliefs that goes with it.
I am doing this openly in a forum not so much as to criticise but to find answers to questions in my mind. The foremost of which is why people choose to believe and run their lives according to unsubstantiated theories. There seems to be a fault in the human thought.Originally posted by Isis:You have to admit that there are many unknown in this world that science has yet to explain and discover. Im not suggesting you should blindly follow or even accept what people in this forum has said. You should explore and uncover buddhism teachings; find something you can relate to spiritually. Faith comes naturally when you can relate to it spirtually.
I was a skeptic of buddhism.When i read the 4 noble truth, i was young and carefree and i cant relate to it at all but as i grow older,sometime things in life make u rethink. Time can remould the way you think...
No matter which religion you believe, as long it make you a happy person.. what does it matters... what the point of all this pointless arguement? For the sake of arguing?
To base your reality solely on your experience is dogmatic and narrow. For example, you did base on ur inaccurate deduction/experience with Buddhism and critcise it openly. It's important to do ur proper research before commenting on any topics.
I suggest u try to immense urself in buddhism.... try meditation, try to attend a dhamma talk or talk to a venerable to answer ur queries about buddhism..
before critcise on it. Of cos, pls make sure u attend the 'correct' buddhism groups.. cos there are some cults using buddhism in name but does not spread correct teachings.
Like people can levitate if they meditate?Originally posted by Isis:what fantastic beliefs? Elaborate more... pls
Pal, we only utilise our brain power in our life 1%, the other 99% latent ability untapped. Those so called genius, utilise the other 99% power to the maximum.Originally posted by casino_king:Like people can levitate if they meditate?
Actually Genius use 2-3% of the brain-power, the rest are not used..Originally posted by marcteng:Pal, we only utilise our brain power in our life 1%, the other 99% latent ability untapped. Those so called genius, utilise the other 99% power to the maximum.
There are other things you are not aware of, which I will refrain from saying here.
To each its own. You will look at this issue differently in 5 years time, trust me.
I also been asking some of the questions you asked when I first started Buddhism, but I am keep my mind open.
So tell me, how are we running our lives on the belief that we can levitate if we meditate?Originally posted by casino_king:Like people can levitate if they meditate?
Again it is precisely because you are using logical reasoning to deal with areas that cannot be comprehended by logic. All these things have already been discussed in previous posts, and I wonder if you have read them.Originally posted by casino_king:Like people can levitate if they meditate?
Very well. Which is why Buddha said,Originally posted by casino_king:So people have this flaw. Many will believe things that others in a uniform... Priest's collar; the nun's habit, and the monk's robe without question.
This is dangerous.
When you are talking about levitating, you are talking about how gravity does not apply. It is not a question of assumption or logic.Originally posted by An Eternal Now:Again it is precisely because you are using logical reasoning to deal with areas that cannot be comprehended by logic. All these things have already been discussed in previous posts, and I wonder if you have read them.
What do you mean by looking at reality? I think Thusness said very well here. It is merely your assumption. Logical assumption. Is logical reasoning REALITY? Far from it. If "logical reasoning" can lead someone to believe that we will never one day fly on aeroplanes, or the world is actually not flat but round, then there is no reason why "logical reasoning" alone cannot lead to the comprehension of spiritual truths.
Let me cite you an example. You are just like a person, who after seeing that a scientist has done certain experiments and proven a scientific fact. Then you say "as far as my experience tell me and by looking at reality, there is simply no evidence of past live and rebirth". The fact is the experiment is done by uncountable people, and you can do it yourself to find out, but instead of doing that experiment you proclaim that just because it is not within your perception it is not true. So what is Reality? Your own perception of "reality"? What Buddha attained is attainable by all of us. The ultimate result is ENLIGHTENMENT, BUDDHAHOOD.
And Thusness also said, you cannot derive answers to spiritual matters through logical deduction. Please read carefully and seriously consider what Thusness said.
A lot more than that have been said in previous posts in regards to this matter.
Also, I have posted a link which I found was interesting. amazing abilities by concentration. Another thing is, in regards to these psychic/paranormal abilities, it is well known that a lot of monks and masters have these. But they do NOT perform miracles publicly because Buddha specifically made a law to forbid it. Only those who are near them will know for certain. Also, I do not need and am not convincing anyone, but I just find it an interesting read, it is up to readers to decide. A person does not necessarily have to believe in levitation to practise Dharma at all, because as I mentioned earlier too, performing so called paranormal abilities is not important in Buddhism.
If you have read my previous post on 'amazing abilities by concentration', you would already have read the answer.Originally posted by casino_king:When you are talking about levitating, you are talking about how gravity does not apply. It is not a question of assumption or logic.
When i said that scientist are beginning to find meditation interesting and beneficial, I and the scientists are not talking about levitating. They are just pointing out that if you learn to concentrate your mind through practising mediation, you will improve your ability to concentrate and that is beneficial for learning and to do many types of work.
You said that paranormal activities are not importamnt to Buddhist teachings. I am of the opinion that if Buddhist can have the illusion that they can levitate through meditation, how much of Buddhist teachings are then based on such illusions?
While I admire Christian teachings I ask myself that if they can believe in God and heaven and hell; how much of Christian teaching is nonsense?
Please don't compare Christianity and Buddhism here.
While I admire Christian teachings I ask myself that if they can believe in God and heaven and hell; how much of Christian teaching is nonsense?
Do you not notice that there is no evidence whatsoever to support all these assertions? Yet you take them as scientific theories.Originally posted by An Eternal Now:If you have read my previous post on 'amazing abilities by concentration', you would already have read the answer.[/i]
Did Buddha specifically state anywhere that you can levitate if you meditate?Originally posted by An Eternal Now:Please don't compare Christianity and Buddhism here.
What Buddha taught is that we can realise and attain whatever he has attained. That no need to have blind faith on authority and his words.
Christian teachings are more emphasized on faith.
In modern science, unexplained phenomena are termed as ANOMOLIES and nobody will bother it because it threatens our world views or we are unable to explain it.Originally posted by casino_king:Do you not notice that there is no evidence whatsoever to support all these assertions? Yet you take them as scientific theories.
While I might even keep an open mind and allow the possibility, I will definately not run my life based on such unproven speculation.
REALITY... keep your focus on REALITY.
Yes, although Buddha and Buddhism places so little emphasize on aspects of paranormal abilities, Buddha did spoke about it before. He himself has also performed miracles.Originally posted by casino_king:Did Buddha specifically state anywhere that you can levitate if you meditate?
Let's say all the scientist become Buddhists. That will be the biggest disaster known to Human kind, no? They will spend time chasing after "unfalsifiable" statements and no new knowledge and no new technology and no new medical discovery and no new .... will come along.Originally posted by An Eternal Now:In modern science, unexplained phenomena are termed as ANOMOLIES and nobody will bother it because it threatens our world views or we are unable to explain it.
There has in fact been many documented cases of such miracles. So many of them! Levitating alone is documented so many but without scientific explanation. I have only given you one website of it. Doctors are also unable to explain certain mysterious, for example for 'Prahlad Jani'. Like I said - Modern Science will not be able to understand these matters anytime soon because so much attention has been directed to the 'outer world' and not the 'inner'.
Secondly, even if I believe that such things exist, as Cenarious pointed out, how does it affect how I live my life? It doesn't at all. That's why Buddhism place so less emphasize on it.
So I say - Keep your Focus on DHARMA.