Originally posted by the Bear:
so.. how do you treat them?
being a schizo is long and far away from people who are doing stupid things in order to gain attention because of "perceived inadequacies"
there are more and more things which are being "discovered"...
maybe everyone should have their regular dose of Soma and be numbed, losing our humanity... welcome to the Brave New World as Huxley saw it.. no one is responsible for anything anymore...
we choose our paths.. and if some person who is so obsessed with his own inadequacies so much that he tops himself, maybe it's some kind of Darwinism at work.. simply because if he's stopped from a swan dive onto concrete over his own wedding tackle, he's going to put his head in an oven over hairloss or someone scratching his car...
where does the mollycoddling end and where does his own responsibility start?
Just because there are folks out there who plead mental and psychological disorders to excuse themselves from paying for some crime they've committed does not mean that these disorders do not exist at all.
There are hereditary causes, chemical deficiencies in the brain, inherent tendencies within certain individuals... those who are genuinely afflicted do not have a choice.
Of course, those who are sane but try to plead insanity, ought to be punished for trying to absolve themselves of all responsibility.
But punish those, do not punish those who genuinely suffer from these disorders. I've worked with entire wards of patients in the IMH and it is very sad to watch at times.
You should know me well enough to know that I am not a bleeding heart and I'm definitely not the mollycoddling sort, and I'm sure those who read my posts know that I definitely am not that sort either!

However, my opinions changed somewhat after having been exposed to people who are diagnosed with these conditions.
Put two people under the same stressful conditions and they'll cope differently. One might snap and plunge into depression, the other just continues fighting to survive. The tendency is to think that if one can make it, why not the other? Sometimes, yes, it's character and emotional weakness in the other person but putting the other person in a stressful condition might actually aggravate a condition that's lurking beneath the veneer anyways.
I think it doesn't do the person any good to accuse them of shirking responsibilities by hiding behind the label of mental disorder because, criminals aside, who really wants to be labelled as 'mentally unstable' and be made to stay in IMH for a while?

Everybody wants to make a good living, but if some can't because of some affliction(s), then if we can't help, we certainly shouldn't impose harsh judgement.
Whenever someone gets diagnosed with a mental disorder, it's not just the victim who gets affected (if he/she still has awareness, that is), the entire family is also dragged down. It's definitely not fun when it happens but if and when it does happen, social support is very important.
Bear, maybe, you might understand more if you were to volunteer at the IMH!
