The Electric New Paper, 26 July 2006
Stunning gown made me stand out
Miss Singapore looks stunning in bikini but her evening gown draws flak for being 'slutty' and unflattering.
She hits back at critics and says she was praised for daring choice
By Celine Lim and Ho Lian-Yi
LIKE a toss-up between 'cabaret' and 'stripper'.
That's just one of the many unkind comments made online about Carol Cheong's evening gown at the Miss Universe 2006 presentation show.
It was held a few days before the main event yesterday, in which Miss Puerto Rico emerged victorious.
Carol, 25, Singapore's representative at the event, failed to make the top 20.
She was not shown wearing that dress on TV, but there was a picture posted on the Miss Universe 2006 website.
It showed her in what looked like a black bra and an ultra miniskirt covered by what looked like a sheer, lacy dress that had its front cut out.
Among the many critical comments posted by local bloggers were: The outfit was 'slutty' and looked more like a night gown than an evening gown.
But Carol was surprised at the criticism as her gown had drawn lots of positive comments in Los Angeles, where the pageant was held.
Speaking to The New Paper over the phone last night, she said: 'At the post-party, quite a few people came up to me and told me that my evening gown was stunning and different.
'They said I stood out from the rest of the girls.'
She said her evening gown had been designed for the Miss Universe contest by her main sponsor, designer Anthea Chan of Perfect in Black.
The outfit consists of a tube top, a satin miniskirt and a full-length lace robe which was studded all over with customised Swarovski crystals.
While Carol had 'no idea' how much the gown costs, she was certain it set her apart from many of the contestants who wore 'white gowns' in 'typical designs'.
And, no, she did not get the chills wearing the revealing black gown as it was 'quite warm on stage in LA as compared to at Mediacorp'.
After the glowing feedback she received, Carol was naturally surprised when The New Paper told her about the negative comments directed at her black evening gown.
Her retort?
'Singaporeans are way too conservative. All they want to see is conventional evening wear.'
She added: 'They should be more supportive of their own delegates and stop putting their representatives down as they have over the past few years.
'I hope Singaporeans will change their mindset because there is a lot of hard work put in by the delegates at international contests like Miss Universe.'
A stronger response came from Mr Errol Pang, the local organiser of the pageant, who exploded with anger when told of the unkind remarks.
'Tell them to mind their own business,' he shot back.
'Everybody here in LA praised the outfit,' said the president of Derrol Stepenny Promotions, which has organised the Miss Singapore/Universe pageant for the past 34 years.
Carol's unusual outfit drew much creative vitriol from members of the so-called 'blogosphere'.
One blog, alexds69.blogspot.com, listed it as among the worst in evening gown in the preliminaries, writing: 'No, Miss Singapore. This is the evening GOWN competition, not the evening SLUT competition.'
A local blog, angeliatay.livejournal.com, also posted about the dress, with the heading 'Yeucks!'
One user on the blog, by the name alisonrae, commented archly: 'I think the designer wanted to make a kebaya but ran out of fabric.'
Another, nicknamed e rambler, complained: 'She must have thought it was night gown competition, not evening gown. So no class the outfit! What were the dressers thinking when they picked her outfits?'
Even members of Singapore's fashion community were taken aback by what they saw.
One of them, fashion photographer Geoff Ang, said it was supposed to look like a (Peranakan) outfit, but it looked like 'she stepped out from the movie set of The Addams Family'.
Did it turn him off?
'Not so much a turn-off, that miniskirt kind of made it a turn-on, but it's wrong from a traditional (Peranakan) outfit point of view!' he said.
He felt the designer tried too hard with the miniskirt.
'And that V-cut at the belly opening may not be the most flattering.'
Fashion stylist Bruce Chin thought the dress was trying to create individuality, but it might not have been a good idea to try it during the Miss Universe pageant, which is still a conventional affair.
'It's nice on its own, but it's not 'evening-ish' enough,' he said.
For him, the top piece was 'fantastic', but the bottom part made her legs look short.
Couture designer Frederick Lee, who has designed for eight Miss Singapore Universe beauties, including Nuraliza Osman, Bernice Wong and Alice Lim, had created another evening gown for Carol, a typically classy, long-skirted red outfit, which also appeared on the website.
Mr Lee, who was designer of the year at Singapore Fashion Awards 2004, would not dress a Miss Universe contestant in a short skirt, as it was, after all, unnecessary.
'If you want to show legs, the swimwear segment is best,' he said.
Celebrity stylist Kenneth Lee said that while he thought the gown was not suitable for her - it made her stomach protrude and 'squashed her short' - he wasn't sure whether it was because of the gown, the photography or Carol herself.
He thought the gown itself was fine. It was ultimately about how a person carries the dress. A person has to know if she can carry a dress or not.
'If you can't, you lose points,' he said.