Gabriel Heinze, Patrice Evra or Mikael Silvestre?
-
Who will you choose as Left-Back? I would not choose Mikael Silvestre as he is prone to mistakes
-
how can you put silvest in the same sentence as heinze and evra
-
That 1 evry1 knowOriginally posted by Dead_Man_Inc:Who will you choose as Left-Back? I would not choose Mikael Silvestre as he is prone to mistakes
For the past few games silvestre played and for the past few games united concede quite an amount of goals -
i choose Evra
-
i choose roberto carlos
-
Gabriel Heinze for his experience, no nonsense defending and very menacing on the left slot.
-
I chose Patrick Evra. He's good.
-
3 are good
-
1. Evra
2. Heinze
3. Silvestre
Cheers.
C.K -
x2Originally posted by CKeer:1. Evra
2. Heinze
3. Silvestre
Cheers.
C.K -
Heinze is the man...
-
i take any one of those two except silvestre...
-
i choose Heinz, he has more experienced and he looks meaner and tougher. his tackles are also more effective. Further more, he can play CD as well.
Evra, looks a weak, and although he is fast, his tackle not that mean and he can be outmuscled. -
i notice heinze got a problem clearing the ball using his head...sometimes during crosses...he end up heading the ball to the opponent..
-
Hi All,
just my opinion, yes, Heinze gives an toughness edge that "Don't mess with me" to all opposing wingers coming down the right lane, but one thing seems to affect him after his injury. His pace. Seems he is a beat slow.
That's why, when we compared with the other two, he seems to be weaker in this aspect.
However, to me, his anticapation and his "never say die" are key to him winning the place in left back.
Evra,showed last night that he is not one to give up. He got pace, and his tackling is good. On top of that, he got that extra edge in his attack.
He seems to link well with either Park, Giggs or Ronaldo.
I think his assets are pace and he is relatively young.
However, his weakness is his aerial where opposing players tend to exploit coming in from the blind side when they cross from the left.
MS is to me, a tank. He got pace, strength, and aerial.
But his weakness is his concentation, and the fact he is soley left-footed.
Being in the league for so long, most opposing players know that if they attack on the right, MS will struggle.
Given his build, he is not as agile as the former two and can't react as fast when situation and thus, he is often caught out.
That's why, I believe MUFC is getting the Saint's left back, and will def sell out either one or even two of these mentioned.
SAF should not stall and should sell while they still have value.
But saying all that, MS has been a faithful servant and has done well.
Let's be reminded more of his good than bad. -
yes...Originally posted by iceFatboy:Hi All,
just my opinion, yes, Heinze gives an toughness edge that "Don't mess with me" to all opposing wingers coming down the right lane, but one thing seems to affect him after his injury. His pace. Seems he is a beat slow.
That's why, when we compared with the other two, he seems to be weaker in this aspect.
However, to me, his anticapation and his "never say die" are key to him winning the place in left back.
Evra,showed last night that he is not one to give up. He got pace, and his tackling is good. On top of that, he got that extra edge in his attack.
He seems to link well with either Park, Giggs or Ronaldo.
I think his assets are pace and he is relatively young.
However, his weakness is his aerial where opposing players tend to exploit coming in from the blind side when they cross from the left.
MS is to me, a tank. He got pace, strength, and aerial.
But his weakness is his concentation, and the fact he is soley left-footed.
Being in the league for so long, most opposing players know that if they attack on the right, MS will struggle.
Given his build, he is not as agile as the former two and can't react as fast when situation and thus, he is often caught out.
That's why, I believe MUFC is getting the Saint's left back, and will def sell out either one or even two of these mentioned.
SAF should not stall and should sell while they still have value.
But saying all that, MS has been a faithful servant and has done well.
Let's be reminded more of his good than bad.
silvestre should retire now...
then we'll remember him more for his good than bad...
everytime he plays... man utd look like conceding goals...
-
Evra of coz !!!