Manchester Utd 1 Middlesbrough 0
Cristiano Ronaldo returned to mere mortal mode on Monday night, but the charismatic winger was still Manchester UnitedÂ’s match-winner in a tense FA Cup quarter-final replay at Old Trafford. Almost inevitably, too, there was a strong whiff of controversy as the Portugal winger won the 76thminute penalty that he himself converted past Middlesbrough goalkeeper Mark Schwarzer to see United through to a semi-final against Watford. Jonathan Woodgate, outstanding at the back as Middlesbrough pushed United all the way, was as convinced as his outraged teammates that his tackle had not sent Ronaldo tumbling. Television replays appeared to show that referee Mike Dean had made the right call, with Woodgate just catching RonaldoÂ’s trailing leg before the United player hit the deck.
But BoroÂ’s frustration as they saw their FA Cup dream disintegrating in the fraught final minutes boiled over when substitute James Morrison was sent off for a foul on Ronaldo near the corner flag. As referee Dean brandished a straight red card at Morrison, who had been on the pitch less than half an hour, Wayne Rooney went charging in to give the England Under 21 midfielder a piece of his mind.
Woodgate was the peacemaker there as Old Trafford pondered the irony of Rooney diving in on RonaldoÂ’s behalf after the World Cup controversy that threatened to wreck the wingerÂ’s United career. But MorrisonÂ’s dismissal did nothing to take the heat out of the situation, and United assistant manager Carlos Queiroz was pulled away from the Middlesbrough bench following an audible cry of "cheat" towards UnitedÂ’s dug-out.
Boro assistant boss Malcolm Crosby and kit man Alex Smith appeared to be the men getting a glare from Queiroz, who has been a mentor to fellow countryman Ronaldo during his time at Old Trafford. Middlesbrough manager Gareth Southgate was clearly one not convinced of the validity of RonaldoÂ’s 18th goal of the season for the club, when he sent Schwarzer the wrong way from the penalty spot.
It probably didnÂ’t help his demeanour either when Ronaldo, having finished celebrating with most of his team-mates, ran past and seemed to gesture to BoroÂ’s manager that he talked too much. Southgate said: "IÂ’m not sure about the penalty, IÂ’ve seen it three times. But the referee has given it, so itÂ’s end of story. Cristiano Ronaldo is a fantastic player and is really good at what he does."
When he does what he does really well, as he did when putting Bolton to the sword just 48 hours earlier, Ronaldo is without a match. He wasnÂ’t quite in that scintillating form on Monday night, however. Even so, he was more than a handful for Boro, well as they played in defence, with Woodgate showing the poise and ability that should make him an essential member of the England squad.
United always had one or two things up their sleeve, such as Ji-Sung ParkÂ’s introduction from the bench when Alan Smith had run himself almost to a standstill and been booked in the process.
In the end, it took Gaby HeinzeÂ’s astute pass, RonaldoÂ’s homing instinct for goal, and WoodgateÂ’s only imperfect tackle of the night to keep UnitedÂ’s Treble bid alive and condemn BoroÂ’s season.
Southgate said: "There were some fantastic performances from my players, and IÂ’m not going to knock them. We came here and took the best team in the country all the way. "We did lose our discipline in the last five minutes and thatÂ’s not acceptable. YouÂ’ve got to be mature but James is a young player."
MANCHESTER UNITED (4-4-2): Kuszczak; Brown, Ferdinand, Vidic, Evra; Ronaldo, Carrick, Giggs, Richardson (Park 60); Smith (OÂ’Shea 71), Rooney.
Booked: Smith, Rooney.
Scorer: Ronaldo 76 (pen).
MIDDLESBROUGH (4-4-2): Schwarzer; Xavier, Woodgate, Pogatetz, Taylor (Huth 8

; Cattermole (Morrison 62), Boateng, Arca (Rochemback 69), Downing; Yakubu, Viduka.
Booked: Xavier, Woodgate, Pogatetz, Rochemback, Boateng.
Sent off: Morrison.
Man of the match: Jonathan Woodgate.
Referee: Mike Dean.