Can forgive but cannot forget.Originally posted by HENG@:their jap culture now did not kill the chinese people in the past. besides they had 2 A-Bombs dropped on them, what more u want? Retribution they already have. Time for forgiveness. can u gurantee that nothing you use has been made by the Japs in one way or another?
Nowadays, we just indulged in materialistic things and forget all about the moral stuff.Originally posted by Weirdo80:The world has long forgiven Japan but we can never forget.
The only reason people think little of the issue of covering up is the fact that they have not experienced the horror of that war. If your father/mother/wife/husband/children were killed by the Japanese, would you not feel enraged by the fact that they want to gloss over their atrocities so that the younger generation will not know how much suffering was endured because of their forefathers? By not taking a firm stance on this we are trivialising our dead, disrespecting them by wiping their memories off the face of the earth.
This issue is more serious than your sushi-eating or Japanese cars. Please don't disrespect the sacrifices that our forefathers have made.
Well said, my friend!Originally posted by Tuatau:Many people don't have problems with the Japanese culture per se. The Japanese work ethics is admirable, their dedication to quality is laudable.
The bone of contention is not with the culture, however. The motive behind the Chinese and Korean boycott is a protest against the adamant refusal of the Japanese to acknowledge the atrocities committed by their expansionist-minded forefathers during World War II. It is indeed time to forgive and many would want to forgive, but forgiveness is meaningless and redundant when the perpetrators do not acknowlege the wrongs committed.
Chinese: "We forgive you..."
Japanese: "Forgive us for what? We deserve gratitude, not forgiveness."
It is debatable whether the bombs dropped at Hiroshima and Nagasaki were acts of retribution. Many historians, especially Americans, consider the bombs as a desperate measure to bring the proud, rather-die-than-surrender Japanese to their knees, to stop the war from prolonging any further. It is possible that without the two bombs in 1945, Singaporeans would be studying their textbooks in Japanese today.
It is like going to one's house and rape the female family members, then proclaimed that you should be thankful because I satisified the sexual urge of the female family members.Originally posted by edenboy:How long do you want to bicker about this issue. The next 10 years, 20 years, until the end of the world.
We now live in a peaceful world.... except for some stupid super power that keeps starting irrelevant wars. Although the Japanese are not will to apologise outright, their actions have spoken louder.
What else do you expect... Them to go down on their knees.
If they do so, I think this world has nothing to look forward to anymore as they no longer need to atone for their sins through actions.
May I know the reasons for not admitting to the horrors committed?Originally posted by FeowFeow:Dear Po Ren,
The Nippons haf their reasons for Not admitting to the atrocities committed during World War II. In addition, I remember a poignant article in which the newer generation Nippons cried when they learnt of the truth. Not all Japanese r heartless pple.
Besides, Japanese food is delish, nutritious & q. healthy (if u dun take the deep fried foods), so why shd we boycott them?
FeowFeow
how can anyone in the world forget? if you can really forgive then you will agree that what is going on in china now is unnecessary. do you? think again.Originally posted by PoRen:Can forgive but cannot forget.
Worse is Japanese history distorted the history.
I salute you!!Originally posted by Tuatau:Yes, the Japanese actions have spoken louder. They have broken their post-war Constitution never to send Self-Defense troops abroad, laid territorial claims on the Dokdo and Senkaku islands, and their Prime Minister Koizumi has visited the Yasukuni National Shrine that glorified their war dead including war criminal Hideki Tojo.
To top it all, they have amended their school history textbooks and are teaching young Japanese kids that Japan was the liberator of Asia by chasing away the European and American colonists, paving the path to independence for countries like Singapore, Malaysia and the Philippines.
There is a reason why Germany but not Japan is a permanent member in the U.N. Security Council.
We may live in a peaceful world, but peace is not to be taken for granted. While I personally bear no animosity against the Japanese per se, mute acceptance of the Japanese actions is tantamount to the acknowledgement of their version of history, and to the implication that the Japanese were indeed fighting a righteous war for the Asian countries they occupied and that these countries should hate the Americans for depriving their youths from studying textbooks in Japanese.
Born in Kandang Kerbau Hospital, what do you think?Originally posted by Devil1976:Are you from China...?![]()
Doing good later but not admitting to your sins, what's the point?Originally posted by dragg:in fact japanese investments have helped more than just singapore. many countries have benefitted from their post-war success.
1. written off a lot of debts of 3rd world countries.
2. financial help offered in time of disaster.
3. loans and support of major projects in various regions.
the list just goes on and on...
whatever atrocities the japanese had committed in the past they have more than made up with all the above. think of the number of people who has benefitted.
please stop comparing them to germany.
germany acknowledged their mistake but sustained no atomic bombs.
japan did not acknowledged their mistake but sustained 2 atomic bombs.
Are you saying that it is OK for the Japanese to distort history? Is that what you are saying my friend?Originally posted by dragg:how can anyone in the world forget? if you can really forgive then you will agree that what is going on in china now is unnecessary. do you? think again.
we will always remember what japan and germany have done. but humans never learn. there were so many wars after WWII. why? POLITICS OF COURSE.
which part of my posting did i even remotely hint that it is ok to distort history?Originally posted by PoRen:Are you saying that it is OK for the Japanese to distort history? Is that what you are saying my friend?
of course ideally we will want japan to acknowledge, apologise and yet give us all their investments. but this is the real world we are living in, however cruel. you know very well we cant have the best of both worlds in this situation. frankly speaking if you really dislike the japanese so much and are so particular about this issue please practice what you preach. boycott all japanese goods and throw away all japanese products you have at home. remember not to board japanese bus or the MRT (japanese too)Originally posted by PoRen:Doing good later but not admitting to your sins, what's the point?
you said earlier you can forgive. obviously you cant.Originally posted by PoRen:Japanese Occupation
Massacre of Chinese Populace
Having gained control over Singapore on February 15, 1942, General Tomoyuki Yamashita instructed the Japanese garrison commander to round up the anti-Japanese elements.
The plan, issued by the Imperial Headquarters, was to gather all Chinese males between the ages of 18 and 50 at various locations, screen them, and execute those identified as anti-Japanese.
Screening centres were set up all over Singapore. Most of them were situated in areas of large Chinese populous. Among them were Java Road, Arab Street, Telok Kurau English School, St. Joseph's Institution, and Chinatown.
At the Chinatown screening centre, lorries were parked nearby ready to take anti-Japanese suspects to remote locations such as Changi, Punggol and Bedok, where they were all massacred.
The lucky ones were stamped with an "examined" word on their faces, arms, clothing or just pieces of paper. They were free to return home to their families afterwards.
We do not know how many men were executed during the Sook Ching exercise.
When the Singapore Chinese Chamber of Commerce, Appeal Committee for Singapore Chinese Victims Massacred by Japanese, attempted to investigate by urging people to report deaths of family members and relatives, only 8600 were reported.
Research have shown that there were many more.
Whatever the number is, Sook Ching will, remain a horrific and traumatic experience in the memory of the survivors.
http://www.s1942.org.sg/dir_defence7.htm
japan did not want to liberate s'poreOriginally posted by FireIce:if not for that 3yrs 8mths, do u think singapore will be wat we are today?
Actually there is a good side to the invasion...Originally posted by FireIce:if not for that 3yrs 8mths, do u think singapore will be wat we are today?
Which is why I am asking you.Originally posted by dragg:which part of my posting did i even remotely hint that it is ok to distort history?
Not when they don't admit to it.Originally posted by dragg:you said earlier you can forgive. obviously you cant.
I don't take the bus (Mercedes is Japanese meh?) or the train (thought from Europe) and I don't own a Japanese car.Originally posted by dragg:of course ideally we will want japan to acknowledge, apologise and yet give us all their investments. but this is the real world we are living in, however cruel. you know very well we cant have the best of both worlds in this situation. frankly speaking if you really dislike the japanese so much and are so particular about this issue please practice what you preach. boycott all japanese goods and throw away all japanese products you have at home. remember not to board japanese bus or the MRT (japanese too)