My Project Superstar Theory
-
Usually, after watching the show, I sort of have an idea who is going into the next round and who's not. It can't be my judgement is so bad.
But alas, some days later I realized my judgement is indeed sooo bad.
Those I think will get in got eliminated.
That set me into thinking: WHY? So that's why I have this theory.
Ok, first let me ask you. There are 4 contestants, A,B,C and D.
Lets say A and B are better than C and D. In the fans and votes aspects. But as the organizer, who would you choose to eliminate and go to the "Fight Back" Round?
I would choose A and B, the reason being they have more fans, meaning more smses( income ) will be generated during the "Fight Back" round.
The main thing is I want to have as many smses as possible, even in the "Fight Back" Round.
So IF my theory is correct, isn't it ironic that those who have more votes will get eliminated?
But we will never know since the result of the votes are not revealed to us, even if they do, we will not know whether the result is genuine.
Just a theory though. Hope I'm wrong. -
just rememer sometimes talent isn't taken into consideration but rather whats on the outside..so superficial..
-
just consider this why did slyvester almost win the singapore idol
-
i heard that that most of the selected contestants are the judges own students horrrr.....probably those that is ousted are not lor..... -
u shld ask why taugay wins....Originally posted by hisoka:just consider this why did slyvester almost win the singapore idol
...becos malays in sg wants to use taugay to win back their face so that they dun xia suay in front of chinese..
-
Originally posted by Mr Fugue:u shld ask why taugay wins....
...becos malays in sg wants to use taugay to win back their face so that they dun xia suay in front of chinese.. -
most contests are rigged. period.Originally posted by starviewer:Usually, after watching the show, I sort of have an idea who is going into the next round and who's not. It can't be my judgement is so bad.
But alas, some days later I realized my judgement is indeed sooo bad.
Those I think will get in got eliminated. -
Just feel its unfair for the contestants.
You can be the best but you can still lose because of votes.
So in the end is the votes that count.
Why not call it Project SMS or Project Votes.
Hope there is one time when someone just stand there, do nothing but get the most votes. The see what the organizer has to say. -
why is it unfair?Originally posted by starviewer:Just feel its unfair for the contestants.
You can be the best but you can still lose because of votes.
So in the end is the votes that count.
Why not call it Project SMS or Project Votes.
Hope there is one time when someone just stand there, do nothing but get the most votes. The see what the organizer has to say.
many so-called heavenly kings cant sing but made millions. that is what entertainment is all about - fans support. -
nothing is fair in this world and being the best doesn't mean u'll survive...Originally posted by starviewer:Just feel its unfair for the contestants.
it's all destined. -
erm superstar means you got alot of idiots aroudn willing to use money to support you mah so noting wrong with voting lorOriginally posted by starviewer:Just feel its unfair for the contestants.
You can be the best but you can still lose because of votes.
So in the end is the votes that count.
Why not call it Project SMS or Project Votes.
Hope there is one time when someone just stand there, do nothing but get the most votes. The see what the organizer has to say. -
true trueOriginally posted by Mr Fugue:u shld ask why taugay wins....
...becos malays in sg wants to use taugay to win back their face so that they dun xia suay in front of chinese.. -
So you think it's fair? So if fan's support is the main source which determines who's going to win, I think Ling Zhilin(she can't sing right?), or David Beckham can win in Project Superstar.Originally posted by dragg:why is it unfair?
So who exactly is Project Superstar looking for: people with talent or people with many many fans? -
well, kelly is in. she deserved it. she 's the best!
-
its about who has richer family, relatives, frens
and who choose not to resort to such. -
dun say, wait she goes out!Originally posted by Gordonator:well, kelly is in. she deserved it. she 's the best! -
if it's a talent contest, then weilian (aka the blind guy) will win.. cos so far he's got the best voice.. but, this isn't a singing contest only leh.Originally posted by stellazio:just rememer sometimes talent isn't taken into consideration but rather whats on the outside..so superficial..
I tot F3 (chanel) sang quite well tonight leh.. damn cool.. if she sang that song last week probably tonight she wouldn't be in this revival thingy liao.. -
watever it is and whoever disqualifies, the host will blame for fans for not voting.
u dont $m$, ur favourite contestant get booted. u lose.
u $m$, ur favourite contestant may or may not gets in, u lose out in phone bill.
and to think tv viewers should have learnt their lesson from nkf. -
AS long kelly n silver r in!
-
Sarport Weilian and Junyang!!
-
i dont think it is fair too. but that is how such things operate. it is all about money, not really about talent.Originally posted by starviewer:So you think it's fair? So if fan's support is the main source which determines who's going to win, I think Ling Zhilin(she can't sing right?), or David Beckham can win in Project Superstar.
So who exactly is Project Superstar looking for: people with talent or people with many many fans?
and you are making a weak comparison. david beckham and lin zhi lin are not singers. even if you disagree come up with someone reasonable!!!
look at the system itself and you have the answers. the judges weightage is only 30%, the public 70%. it is obvious that the fans will eventually determine who wins the contest. who are the people who actually call in to vote? they are either the friends and relatives of the contestant (whom are definitely biased) and kids. (whom will mostly go for looks)
do you think the adult mass will call to vote? maybe only a very small percentage. -
You wun be a superstar when u can sing but no ppl buy your album or no ppl willing to spent they cash on u...
-
Why think so much..??Originally posted by starviewer:Usually, after watching the show, I sort of have an idea who is going into the next round and who's not. It can't be my judgement is so bad.
But alas, some days later I realized my judgement is indeed sooo bad.
Those I think will get in got eliminated.
That set me into thinking: WHY? So that's why I have this theory.
Ok, first let me ask you. There are 4 contestants, A,B,C and D.
Lets say A and B are better than C and D. In the fans and votes aspects. But as the organizer, who would you choose to eliminate and go to the "Fight Back" Round?
I would choose A and B, the reason being they have more fans, meaning more smses( income ) will be generated during the "Fight Back" round.
The main thing is I want to have as many smses as possible, even in the "Fight Back" Round.
So IF my theory is correct, isn't it ironic that those who have more votes will get eliminated?
But we will never know since the result of the votes are not revealed to us, even if they do, we will not know whether the result is genuine.
Just a theory though. Hope I'm wrong. -
Whatever... Its about MARKET VALUE. If you DON'T have it. They do so muchh for you, for f*ck? Even running 'Charity shows' have much more to benefit from...?Originally posted by stellazio:just rememer sometimes talent isn't taken into consideration but rather whats on the outside..so superficial..
-
Hi,Originally posted by dragg:and you are making a weak comparison. david beckham and lin zhi lin are not singers. even if you disagree come up with someone reasonable!!!
I don't think you understand what I'm trying to say.
I purposely picked them because they are NOT singers, but because they have many fans.
Since we all agree that voting is the deciding factor for a person to win, I mean Ling Zhilin or Beckham will win right ( if they took part )? Even if they can't sing.