philosophy... i need some input
-
some experts may have acquired knowledge that is difficult to describe in words. does this mean that other ways of knowing (reason, emotion, and perception) play a more important role than language in knowing how to do something?
-
As a kneejerk reaction, I would say yes
-
Read Heidegger?Originally posted by jenn_y:some experts may have acquired knowledge that is difficult to describe in words. does this mean that other ways of knowing (reason, emotion, and perception) play a more important role than language in knowing how to do something?
-
why yes or no?
-
go read up on Heidegger and Wittgenstein. Heidegger's 'ready to hand' is about perception. Not to forget Wittgenstein and his language games.Originally posted by jenn_y:why yes or no?
These will help you formulate angles and tackle the question. -
i have read about the language game, but i do not see how it demonstrates that language play a role in knowing how to do something.
what role does language, emotion, perception, and reason play in knowing how to ride a bike? -
i would say yes. that explains why some people are able to pick up things more easily than others. But language, although inadequate in conveying all the non-linguistic aspects of a skill, is often the only medium we have of trying to explain how to pick up a skill.
-
hmm..
deep stuff. -
X 2. It's a communication bridge and much more....Originally posted by HENG@:i would say yes. that explains why some people are able to pick up things more easily than others. But language, although inadequate in conveying all the non-linguistic aspects of a skill, is often the only medium we have of trying to explain how to pick up a skill. -
i've got my outline:
I. Introduction
1. What is knowing how?
2. Differentiate between knowing that and knowing how
3. Thesis: Language play an important role in knowing how to do something
II. Knowing How and WOK
1. Knowing how and Perception
2. Knowing how and Reason
3. Knowing how and Emotion
4. Knowing how and Language
III. Language and other WOK
1. Language and Perception
2. Language and Reason
3. Language and Emotion
IV. Conclusion
if i were to tell u how to ride a bicycle, would u know how to do so right away? or do u have to learn how to ride a bicycle. thus, what role does language play then in knowing how to do something? -
* sniff sniff *
sounds like a school assingment to me
-
mahahahaha. oh poor jenn. I never liked writing essays like this. Then again engineering isn't more fun either. If u wanna I can have a bit of discussion about this topic with u. MSN me at... 5am sgforums time tonite. I should be home from uni by then
-
Hmm... The outline's machiam like some books I've read before...?Originally posted by jenn_y:i've got my outline:
I. Introduction
1. What is knowing how?
2. Differentiate between knowing that and knowing how
3. Thesis: Language play an important role in knowing how to do something
II. Knowing How and WOK
1. Knowing how and Perception
2. Knowing how and Reason
3. Knowing how and Emotion
4. Knowing how and Language
III. Language and other WOK
1. Language and Perception
2. Language and Reason
3. Language and Emotion
IV. Conclusion
if i were to tell u how to ride a bicycle, would u know how to do so right away? or do u have to learn how to ride a bicycle. thus, what role does language play then in knowing how to do something?