Mahjong Question~!!

• Axelheat755

  6 Jun 06, 16:09

  If u "Ping Hu", u got 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 9 bamboo. U eat a 4 bamboo and discard 8 bamboo, can u win if someone throw a 5 or 8 in the same round? Any experts around?
• dragg

  6 Jun 06, 16:11

  cannot.
  
  but if all your tiles are bamboo you have one colour. why bother about ping hu?
  
  
• Axelheat755

  6 Jun 06, 16:12

  someone tell me if throw 8 u can eat 5 to win. another tell me can eat both but ONLY if u waiting. so now i'm confused
• Ah Cek

  6 Jun 06, 16:13

  u can only take 5 bamboo to win
• Axelheat755

  6 Jun 06, 16:13

  Originally posted by dragg:

  cannot.
  
  but if all your tiles are bamboo you have one colour. why bother about ping hu?
  
  

  not one colour la.
  
• dragg

  6 Jun 06, 16:15

  Originally posted by Axelheat755:

  someone tell me if throw 8 u can eat 5 to win. another tell me can eat both but ONLY if u waiting. so now i'm confused

  cannot again.
  
  ping hu cannot win with ka loong unless you chee more.
  
  
• dragg

  6 Jun 06, 16:15

  Originally posted by Ah Cek:

  u can only take 5 bamboo to win

  cannot lah.
  
  
• Camellias4me

  6 Jun 06, 16:16

  If u eat a 4 le... cannot be ping hu.. is "smelly" ping hu liao.
  
  Ping hu means no pong no eat no flower nothing...
  U can wait for 5 or 8 yes.. but dat will be "smelly" ping hu..
• homerun

  6 Jun 06, 16:16

  Originally posted by Axelheat755:

  If u "Ping Hu", u got 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 9 bamboo. U eat a 4 bamboo and discard 8 bamboo, can u win if someone throw a 5 or 8 in the same round? Any experts around?

  got to wait for the next round....
• dragg

  6 Jun 06, 16:18

  Originally posted by Camellias4me:

  If u eat a 4 le... cannot be ping hu.. is "smelly" ping hu liao.
  
  Ping hu means no pong no eat no flower nothing...
  U can wait for 5 or 8 yes.. but dat will be "smelly" ping hu..

  thats char wu.
  
  he can only win with 5 and 8 when his turn comes again after eating the 4.
  
  
• Camellias4me

  6 Jun 06, 16:18

  next time dun eat... zi mor!
• Axelheat755

  6 Jun 06, 16:19

  Originally posted by Camellias4me:

  If u eat a 4 le... cannot be ping hu.. is "smelly" ping hu liao.
  
  Ping hu means no pong no eat no flower nothing...
  U can wait for 5 or 8 yes.. but dat will be "smelly" ping hu..

  huh? r u sure u play mahjong? ping hu cannot pong n no flowers only. who say cannot eat?
• dragg

  6 Jun 06, 16:21

  Originally posted by Camellias4me:

  If u eat a 4 le... cannot be ping hu.. is "smelly" ping hu liao.
  
  Ping hu means no pong no eat no flower nothing...
  U can wait for 5 or 8 yes.. but dat will be "smelly" ping hu..

  what is no eat?
  
  
• Axelheat755

  6 Jun 06, 16:21

  Originally posted by dragg:

  thats char wu.
  
  he can only win with 5 and 8 when his turn comes again after eating the 4.
  
  

  so must wait for next round right?
• homerun

  6 Jun 06, 16:21

  Originally posted by Camellias4me:

  If u eat a 4 le... cannot be ping hu.. is "smelly" ping hu liao.
  
  Ping hu means no pong no eat no flower nothing...
  U can wait for 5 or 8 yes.. but dat will be "smelly" ping hu..

  ping hu can eat....cannot pong....cannot have flower or animal...cannot have big tile as yr "eyes"(meaning no "zhong".."fa"..yr own wind...etc). Lastly cannot wait for 1 tile to win(7 and 9 cannot wait for 8 )
• Axelheat755

  6 Jun 06, 16:21

  Originally posted by Ah Cek:

  u can only take 5 bamboo to win

  can eat 5 bamboo to win in the same round u discard a 8 bamboo?
• dragg

  6 Jun 06, 16:23

  Originally posted by homerun:

  ping hu can eat....cannot pong....cannot have flower or animal...cannot have big tile as yr "eyes"(meaning no "zhong".."fa"..yr own wind...etc). Lastly cannot wait for 1 tile to win(7 and 9 cannot wait for

  but you can use dong, nan, xi, bei as your eyes as long as it is not your own or the current wind.
  
  
• Camellias4me

  6 Jun 06, 16:23

  Originally posted by Axelheat755:

  huh? r u sure u play mahjong? ping hu cannot pong n no flowers only. who say cannot eat?

  can eat... but eat liao not considered ping hu.. they call it chao ping hu...
  
• homerun

  6 Jun 06, 16:24

  Originally posted by Axelheat755:

  can eat 5 bamboo to win in the same round u discard a 8 bamboo?

  i dun think so...cos if u throw 8 ..people expect u not to win on 5 bamboo)
• dragg

  6 Jun 06, 16:24

  Originally posted by Axelheat755:

  can eat 5 bamboo to win in the same round u discard a 8 bamboo?

  cannot.
  
  you can only win with 5 or 9 when your turn comes again.
• homerun

  6 Jun 06, 16:24

  Originally posted by Camellias4me:

  can eat... but eat liao not considered ping hu.. they call it chao ping hu...
  

  it is still ping hu
• Camellias4me

  6 Jun 06, 16:26

  Originally posted by homerun:

  it is still ping hu

  orr.. paiseh.. sala info
• Ah Cek

  6 Jun 06, 16:28

  Originally posted by Axelheat755:

  can eat 5 bamboo to win in the same round u discard a 8 bamboo?

  yup.
• homerun

  6 Jun 06, 16:28

  Originally posted by dragg:

  but you can use dong, nan, xi, bei as your eyes as long as it is not your own or the current wind.
  
  

  correct...that y i say own wind
• DriftingGuy

  6 Jun 06, 16:30

  Originally posted by homerun:

  ping hu can eat....cannot pong....cannot have flower or animal...cannot have big tile as yr "eyes"(meaning no "zhong".."fa"..yr own wind...etc). Lastly cannot wait for 1 tile to win(7 and 9 cannot wait for 8 )

  Walao so stringent.. Like that how many tai/fan? Expect at least 3 right?