Originally posted by smart_boy_only:why student have not coroporal punishment now?
i still rmb in pri sch...
there's this mad woman (teacher) who LOVES to throw our exercise books on the floor~~ she threw so many times that the pages always come off..
& we often have to use rubber band to tie our exercise books~
She loves to hold on to 1 long wooden ruler also..whereby she will hit us on the knuckles *ouch*
Originally posted by despondent:some things i wanna add b4 sharing abt the aftermath of the incident above…the 3 of us were rather shocked tat time by wad my tutor did to my frend’s bro. none of us expected her to punish him so harshly even though she had meted out punishments b4…to us, the punishment was rather harsh n even our tutor admitted tat(will share more abt tis). the pain my frend’s bro suffered from prolonged standing was unforgettable to us…
for myself, i was also punished in a similar way once. however, the suffering i went thru was much less..i was in sec 1 tat yr…we juz had a spelling test which i failed…our tutor scolded me for doing badly n asked if i studied at all…when she saw the guilt on my face, she got angry n chided me for being lazy…in the end, i was told to push in my chair n stand at a corner next to the table. i was punished in the exact manner as my frend’s bro n ordered to study my spelling…
i was let off after abt half an hr…the tutor decided to postpone my spelling to the next lesson but i had to prepare 2 sets of spelling words…the lesson went on as normal after tat…i can stil remember tat my legs did feel a little tired at the end of half hr. hence i can understand how my frend’s bro must have felt from standing for one n a half hrs…it must be stated tat our tutor made us stand wif our legs tgr n we were nt allowed to stand on one leg at all…standing in such a manner can be very tiring on the long run which was clearly seen from my frend’s bro’s case…
its ur tutor nia,why like so scared of her..u pay for her to teach u u can fire her anytime mah..
Evil people abound. Lets keep together to eliminate them.
Originally posted by despondent:hello, yup i am back to give an account of the case i mentioned in my above post. first of all, i muz state that the teacher being mentioned taught my class onli one subject tat yr n she onli came into our class once a wk. her lessons were an hr long(double periods). i recall tat even when she punished us, she usually would nt punish us for the entire 2 periods. usually she would punish us for one period at the most. moreover, she usually resorted to punishments onli when it was a repeated offence...
however, i remember a case tat yr when she punished a student for the entire 2 periods...he was a repeated offender. moreover, he made things worse by disobeying her orders and slacking when doing punishment. the teacher came into class tat day n told us to hand in our hmwork...this student was found nt to have done his hmwork again...previously, the teacher had let him off lightly...the 1st time he was given a warning n his name was recorded down. the 2nd time, he was made to stand n pull his ears in front of the class for nearly one period. for tis case, the teacher was realli furious n scolded him quite badly. tis time she sent him out of the class...he was asked to stand in the middle of the corridor and pull his ears...
abt halfway thru the 1st period, the teacher saw the student slacking...he was standing on one leg n he was merely holding on to both his ears wif onli 2 fingers...infuriated, the teacher went out of the class...she scolded him for slacking n ordered him to stand properly...initially she ordered him to pull his ears harder but then changed her mind...she ordered him to raise up both his hands and to keep them straight up...after giving a final warning nt to slack, the teacher went back into the classroom...
in the end, the student had to keep his hands raised for abt half an hr!!! in fact, the teacher would have kept him at it until end of lesson if he had nt shown signs of weariness n pain. moreover, the teacher onli allow him to put his hands down after he promised to pull his ears properly...so in the end, the student spent abt the last 15min standing outside the class n pulling his ears hard...he was let off onli at the end of the lesson...on top of tat, the teacher made him stay back after sch to complete his hmwork...he was made stand at his table n do his hmwork...
tat was the onli cae tat yr tat the teacher showed her true colours...but i felt the student deserved it though i feel the punishment was rather harsh...yet, given his rebellion n disobedience, such a punishment was needed to teach him a lesson...
Originally posted by despondent:well, i dunno how the teacher would have punished him as the 4th time never happened…however, an intelligent guess would be the teacher would summon his parents to sch or send the student to the principal’s office. yet b4 all these, the teacher may 1st make the student do punishment for 2 entire periods…i have no idea how she would have punished him although i noe for sure tat she wil nt punish him lightly since its the 4th offence…
Originally posted by despondent:bq.for myself, i was also punished in a similar way once. however, the suffering i went thru was much less..i was in sec 1 tat yr…we juz had a spelling test which i failed…our tutor scolded me for doing badly n asked if i studied at all…when she saw the guilt on my face, she got angry n chided me for being lazy…in the end, i was told to push in my chair n stand at a corner next to the table. i was punished in the exact manner as my frend’s bro n ordered to study my spelling…
i was let off after abt half an hr…the tutor decided to postpone my spelling to the next lesson but i had to prepare 2 sets of spelling words…the lesson went on as normal after tat…i can stil remember tat my legs did feel a little tired at the end of half hr. hence i can understand how my frend’s bro must have felt from standing for one n a half hrs…it must be stated tat our tutor made us stand wif our legs tgr n we were nt allowed to stand on one leg at all…standing in such a manner can be very tiring on the long run which was clearly seen from my frend’s bro’s case…bq.
regarding the case above, i was in a way fortunate tat i made sure i studied for my spelling test the following lesson. i realli dunno wad would have happened if i failed my spelling test again cos i didnt study it. i believe my tutor might go one step further n make me stand for the entire lesson which was abt one n a half hrs!!! cos i remember tat my tutor did sternly warn me to study my spelling or she will not let me off lightly…my case happened b4 my frend’s bro’s case n it was onli after he was punished in such a harsh manner tat i started to realise tat i may have suffered the same fate if i had not heeded her warning…nw when i tink back, i cun help but count my blessings tat i didnt have to suffer tat kind of pain n tiredness in my legs like my frend’s bro did…
Originally posted by despondent:wad u have mentioned is a common punishment which may or may nt be useful…my tutor then did mete out such punishments at times. it must be stated tat my tutor was one who had a wide range of punishment methods although in the yrs she taught us, she onli meted out a few of them. there were times she was angry n would verbally threaten to punish us in interesting ways if we chose nt to comply to her instructions…it turned out tat she nvr had to use any of those ways to punish us although she did share tat she had punished some of her other students in those ways b4..i can still remember some of these interesting ways…will post them next…
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0hswvYvJKmE&feature=related
an interesting punishment tat is quite similar to 2 other cases i cited which took place when i was in pri school. the punishment was indeed very harsh. those of u who have been following tis show shld noe tat the 2 police trainees were punished for the entire lesson. in the scene tat followed, one of the fellow trainee in tat class asked one of them if he was feeling tired from the punishment. a smart guess would suggest tat they were punished for at least half an hr to an hr...
one observation i make is tat tis kind of punishment seems to be very common in military shows where trainees r been trained to be soldiers or police. in one of my earlier posts, 3 female soldiers were punished in a similar way cos they were caught toking during mealtimes...there was also the cases when 3 boys who were being trained to be fighters were made to do recitation 100 times while standing in a knee-bent position n also megan zhang in the local movie home run where she had to do half-squats while reciting: I must not tell lies again...hmmm...seems like tis form of punishment is rather popular...
Originally posted by despondent:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0hswvYvJKmE&feature=related
an interesting punishment tat is quite similar to 2 other cases i cited which took place when i was in pri school. the punishment was indeed very harsh. those of u who have been following tis show shld noe tat the 2 police trainees were punished for the entire lesson. in the scene tat followed, one of the fellow trainee in tat class asked one of them if he was feeling tired from the punishment. a smart guess would suggest tat they were punished for at least half an hr to an hr...
one observation i make is tat tis kind of punishment seems to be very common in military shows where trainees r been trained to be soldiers or police. in one of my earlier posts, 3 female soldiers were punished in a similar way cos they were caught toking during mealtimes...there was also the cases when 3 boys who were being trained to be fighters were made to do recitation 100 times while standing in a knee-bent position n also megan zhang in the local movie home run where she had to do half-squats while reciting: I must not tell lies again...hmmm...seems like tis form of punishment is rather popular...
Originally posted by despondent:ok…as promised, here is one of the interesting punishment tat my tutor told us abt…according to her, tis punishment was onli meted out once b4 to a pri 5 student she tutored several yrs b4 she tutored us…it was a very shameful n humiliating punishment n she onli meted it cos the student repeatedly refused to study his spelling or his work…
according to our tutor, she made it a pt to inform the boy’s parents abt his laziness b4 punishing him…the boy’s parents gave her the authority to punish him over the fone…the lesson was held at our tutor’s hse n there were 3 other students there…our tutor sternly ordered tat student to stand at a corner while she went to get sth…soon, she emerged wif a blouse n a short skirt…she then beckoned the student to the kitchen. moments later, the student was crying n pleading wif her in the kitchen. apparently, our tutor had ordered him to remove his clothes n put on the blouse n skirt. she also colored his lips wif lipstick n ordered him to go n stand in the middle of the living room, face the other 3 students n pull his ears. the student, of cuz didnt dare to leave the kitchen but our tutor was adamant n despite his pleas, made him do wad she had ordered him to do. needless to say, the other 3 students could not contain their laughter when they saw him…it was onli when our tutor sternly warned them not to laugh or they too wil be punished tat they stopped laughing…
i stil rem tat when we heard tis account from our tutor, we didnt noe whether to laugh or to cry. we could imagine how humiliating n ashamed the boy would have felt. according to our tutor, he juz stood there pulling his ears, dressed like a gal n crying thru out. his head was lowered n it was obvious he felt very embarrassed. the gd thing for him was our tutor didnt punish him for the whole lesson. she let him off after abt 20min. we then asked her how the parents felt abt wad she did n she told us tat the parents didnt blame her cos they also felt tat their son needed to be tot a lesson. well all i can say is, its without a doubt tat the boy was tot a very gd lesson. he did become a better student after tat…
Originally posted by xiiaostarry:i still rmb in pri sch...
there's this mad woman (teacher) who LOVES to throw our exercise books on the floor~~ she threw so many times that the pages always come off..
& we often have to use rubber band to tie our exercise books~
She loves to hold on to 1 long wooden ruler also..whereby she will hit us on the knuckles *ouch*
That would be the 90s....no?![]()
![]()
![]()
Originally posted by despondent:harlo!!! yupyup...for the old-timers in sgforums...u may find tis familiar...but i juz tot i will post tis in a diff. forum...
all of us i believe have had our fair share of being punished in school. some punishments r more physical while others more psychological...physical ones include caning, CWO, kneeling or standing for long periods etc...psychological ones like pulling of ears, facing the wall, being ask to sing in front of whole class etc...i personally feel tat diff. punishments shld vary wif the severity of offences n the age of the student involved...surely u wun wanna shame a university student by punishing him like a primary schoolboy?
below is a true account of a student i noe who was punished by a teacher...he was punished for spewing 1 word of vulgarity...
student: @#%()&*&^%$%^*
teacher: U!!! COME HERE!!! HOW DARE U SAY TAT!!! COME HERE!!!
boy approaches n teacher scolded: WAD DID U SAY JUZ NW?! I DARE U TO REPEAT WAD U SAID JUZ NW!!!
STUDENT: i didnt say anything...
teacher: DUN DENY IT ALRITE!!! I HEARD WAD U SAID!!! I HEARD U!!!(pulls student to 1 corner) SLAP URSELF!!! SLAP!!! KEEP ON SLAPPING!!
(abt 10 min later) teacher: U R NT SLAPPING...U R PATTING!!!(pulls student out of class) dun wanna slap rite...face the whole school n slap...
in the end, DM happen to walk pass...teacher complained abt student to him n student was caned in front of whole class...
after the caning...
teacher: COME HERE!!! (pulls student to one corner) STAND HERE N CONTINUE TO SLAP URSELF!!! I WANT SLAPS NT PATS!!! (student began to slap himself) U CALL TAT SLAPPING? HARDER!!! (student slaps harder) ALRITE!!! KEEP IT TAT WAY!!!
after abt 5min...
teacher(points finger at student): U R NT SLAPPING AGAIN!!! I TOLD U TO SLAP HARD RITE!!! HOW DARE U DISOBEY MY ORDERS!!! DO U WANT ANOTHER ROUND OF PUBLIC CANING??? (student began slapping himself hard again) MAKE SURE U KEEP TIS UP UNTIL I SAY U CAN STOP, ONE MORE TIME...N U WILL GET IT FROM ME!!! I WANT EVERY SLAP TO BE EQUALLY HARD, DO U UNDERSTAND???
in the end, student was made to slap himself for another 10-15 min...he had red cheeks after tat n had teary eyes...thru out the time, we could hear the slaps coming from his cheeks...the teacher kept an eye on him at regular intervals to ensure every slap was hard, she gave him no chance to slack at all...wad r ur views abt tis? was the teacher too harsh? was the student deserving of the punishment? air them here...
how old is the student and at which level of education is he in?