Originally posted by Aveme:
ermm technically your theory is not correct.
HDB flats generally keep their value or likely appreciate so if you have wanted to,you can sell it away for that amount of $$ back which you can then decide to give it as an inheritance
Car?k maybe not but well the theory is just that its value depreciate alot and you will not get back much but still you accepted that when you buy it thus you did accept the ownership of a car for 10 years,if it was truely leased like what you said,after 10 years,do you return the car to the govt? No,at the very worst,you can sell it for scrap which is not much thou,but still the scrap is for you to sell.
If you have enough money left after all these heavy expenditure and invested wisely,these are also your ownership and is free for you to be given as an inheritance too provided that for all your stuff,you draw up a proper will if not good luck,the govt will tax the hell of out it.
Beside these are all material stuff,you can't even take any of these with you when your time is up,ownership or not,it does not really matters at the end of the day
That's cause so far flats have only been around on a massive scale for about 50 yrs max. Once the lease runs to about 30 yrs, you are sunk with a declining value property for sure.
This scenario goes against the argument of wanting "property owners" rather than renters so that they have more stake and will upkeep their property.
The more "renovations" "upkeep" you put into mortar and bricks is NOT yours at the end of the day, so you put your money into other things that you can take with you.
The solution for permanence and belonging is to create "Ancestor-class" flats which are huge flats that 2-3 generations of NS serviced, native-Singaporeans can buy, freehold, together, and set up in trust, with a professional plus family nominated management of the property.
These properties will be like the villages/mansions, estates of people from larger countries who can identify their roots.
We will have a situation where people can then say, they hail from Ghim Moh, or from Sembawang, and their "ancestral" lodgings will remain theirs in perpetuity.
These properties will serve as respite for smaller family nuclei who are down and out. (Many of my friends in US/Europe, when they lose their jobs, failed business, etc.) can always GO HOME. The ancestral properties are large enough to accomodate them, keep their belongings for storage for a long time, a bastion of peace in a life of struggle and competition.
We need that to bolster a sense of tradition and nationhood by forming new tribe spaces in a Singaporean context.