Teacher hit my head with Exercise Book.
-
it all link to one thing......wad is going on when they are trained?
-
yes, hitting the student on the head is wrong...Originally posted by jojobeach:Yah lor, why not start ARMY training after the kids graduate from PSLE ?
but will it cause him so much stress that he has to publish this story in Stomp, sgf and who knows what other forums on the net....
and most importantly, has the TS told us the full story?
and why publish the name of the teacher and the school...
most of the comments here stem from the fact that the TS has not been entirely truthful here... and the fact that the student is making a mountain out of a molehill... -
Mr Lim Lao Peh,Originally posted by Father Lim:yes, hitting the student on the head is wrong...
but will it cause him so much stress that he has to publish this story in Stomp, sgf and who knows what other forums on the net....
and most importantly, has the TS told us the full story?
and why publish the name of the teacher and the school...
most of the comments here stem from the fact that the TS has not been entirely truthful here... and the fact that the student is making a mountain out of a molehill...
How do you know he is not emotionally affected by what the teacher did ?
Just because he is a kid does not means he is without pride and ego.
Yes it is true, what he did reeks of vengence. But it is better than internalizing the hatred within himself. And we wonder why some kids goes into his own school and randomly kills . Think.
By publishing the name of the teacher and the school.
The school in-charge will inevitably have to look into this matter and provide some answers to what had happened.
Do you really believe TS will not have to deal with dishing out the truth when that happens ?
Nothing is a molehill when teachers whom we trust our children to, strikes a helpless child. -
"Last time my teacher slap me" "Last time my teacher kick me" "Last time my teacher throw stuffs at me"
Hello?! Who cares about last time. No one complains what teachers did last time doesn't make it right this time. Last time, maybe some students want to complain but afraid to, or doesn't know the proper way/person to complain to. So they have no choice but to let it go. The sh!t we gone through doesn't mean that the others need to suffer from it too.
We should try to stand up & help the students instead of bringing up how the teachers have abused you previously & compare it, brushing it off using the excuse of "Only an exercise book so its okie."
Although it's just an exercise book, but that is not the point of whether she is using a light weight object or a heavy one. It's the way the teachers sent the message across to students that counts. The teachers can jolly well give him detention rather than hit him.
Tho i think TS should have complain to the school 1st or something. -
How about saying something new? This line has been done to death in this thread by all the strong and silent types who made nary a whimper when they got hit by their teachers, even though they, just like the TS, conveniently forgot to share what they did to deserve such treatment.Originally posted by SBS3625D:If like that cannot, I honestly dunno how TS is gonna survive army.
Your teachers hit you and you guys kept silent. So Singapore should have also kept quiet when Malaysia contested Pedra Branca lah?
Wankers....
-
many of the posters here have been punished for some misdemeanors or others... but we have the sense of decency to know that we were in the wrong first...Originally posted by jojobeach:Mr Lim Lao Peh,
How do you know he is not emotionally affected by what the teacher did ?
Just because he is a kid does not means he is without pride and ego.
Yes it is true, what he did reeks of vengence. But it is better than internalizing the hatred within himself. And we wonder why some kids goes into his own school and randomly kills . Think.
By publishing the name of the teacher and the school.
The school in-charge will inevitably have to look into this matter and provide some answers to what had happened.
Do you really believe TS will not have to deal with dishing out the truth when that happens ?
Nothing is a molehill when teachers whom we trust our children to, strikes a helpless child.
if the TS is not at fault, why not complain to the school first...
why bring this up to the media and publish the school and teacher's name...
isn't there a better way to deal with this?? and most importantly, why is there a recording of this incident??
yes, in the end, the TS will have to dish out the truth... but the identity of the teacher is already out in the open... no matter what, the teacher is already the loser in this incident, while the student at most will get a light punishment, if he even gets that...
and no student is ever helpless... they have much more power over teachers than teachers over them...
yes, beating the student is wrong... it might have been acceptable in the past but not now...
so think, which teacher would resort to that knowing that their livelihood would be in trouble... -
You say it easy, sir, that we should find our own faults. But how many people can realize their own faults before they even confess of their own faults. Sometimes when teachers punish students, they must have a reason behind it. If the reason is made unknown, who the hell will realize what exactly was the cause?
-
Originally posted by Boy Stratus:
I so totally agree with Boy Stratus..
"Last time my teacher slap me" "Last time my teacher kick me" "Last time my teacher throw stuffs at me"
Hello?! Who cares about last time. [b]No one complains what teachers did last time doesn't make it right this time. Last time, maybe some students want to complain but afraid to, or doesn't know the proper way/person to complain to. So they have no choice but to let it go. The sh!t we gone through doesn't mean that the others need to suffer from it too.
While everybody is entitled to his or her own views, there would be differences in thinking whether the TS did the right thing to air his woes like this. Nobody can ever be an objective-enough judge anyway.
Yes, it is certainly wrong for a teacher to hit a student on the head, regardless of what the student had done. I am not saying though that the TS did the right thing to share on the thread, but then.. people are always too quick to judge.. -
Mr Lim Lau Peh,Originally posted by Father Lim:many of the posters here have been punished for some misdemeanors or others... but we have the sense of decency to know that we were in the wrong first...
if the TS is not at fault, why not complain to the school first...
why bring this up to the media and publish the school and teacher's name...
isn't there a better way to deal with this?? and most importantly, why is there a recording of this incident??
yes, in the end, the TS will have to dish out the truth... but the identity of the teacher is already out in the open... no matter what, the teacher is already the loser in this incident, while the student at most will get a light punishment, if he even gets that...
and no student is ever helpless... they have much more power over teachers than teachers over them...
yes, beating the student is wrong... it might have been acceptable in the past but not now...
so think, which teacher would resort to that knowing that their livelihood would be in trouble...
I am not a law enforcement officer.
But if you read news.
Identities of juveniles are always kept secret.
If the teacher is indeed innocent.. ( unlikely) the school will make a public aware of it through the media too.
No, I don't agree that students wields more power than the teachers.
There are many more cases of teacher abuse that goes under the radar because students are too fearful of retaliation by the authorities. -
Originally posted by wilsonhao:NS got councillor wat, so that when mistreated the armies can go tell them about their problems and so on. The society has changed alr. 20th and 21th century like you all have said is very much a difference. Is not whether we can endure it or not. When the society has developed, people developed too. In those days torture might not be as ruthless as people can think of now. People gets more violent. So of course if you were to say maintain the standard it was used to be, i think that is impossible.
Tell that to someone who got whacked on the head by a M-16 magazine before.
Please lah...
I'm not talking endurance here, but rather....how should I put it? -
HOHO HOO.......don't make me laugh. Helpless?Originally posted by jojobeach:Mr Lim Lao Peh,
How do you know he is not emotionally affected by what the teacher did ?
Just because he is a kid does not means he is without pride and ego.
Yes it is true, what he did reeks of vengence. But it is better than internalizing the hatred within himself. And we wonder why some kids goes into his own school and randomly kills . Think.
By publishing the name of the teacher and the school.
The school in-charge will inevitably have to look into this matter and provide some answers to what had happened.
Do you really believe TS will not have to deal with dishing out the truth when that happens ?
Nothing is a molehill when teachers whom we trust our children to, strikes a helpless child.
Ok lah, there are helpless ones, but this fellow here is DEFINITELY not HELPLESS.
Just another attention-seeker. Why? Do you have to beat your chest and sing your school anthem here for my sympathy? Just a simple story will do.
There's more than meets the eye here. -
Who , you ? Why you so stupid kept quiet for so long ?Originally posted by SBS3625D:
Tell that to someone who got whacked on the head by a M-16 magazine before.
Please lah...
I'm not talking endurance here, but rather....how should I put it? -
Anything wrong with that?Originally posted by jojobeach:Who , you ? Why you so stupid kept quiet for so long ?
I just had my lunch. -
A teacher will not hit someone without reason especially IN SINGAPORE,
with all the mother father son daughter who like to complain over a little thing,
especially:
A teacher in XXX sch whack my son's head with a text book.
A teacher in XXXX sch asked my daughter to stand on the chair just becoz my daughter wore a black clolorful bra.
oh hell grammr problem -
i beg to differ.. if they are primary skul kids who keep mum abt the teachers' behaviour, it will be another scenario altogether..Originally posted by kiss_my (_i_):A teacher will not hit someone without reason especially IN SINGAPORE,
with all the mother father son daughter who like to complain over a little thing,
especially:
A teacher in XXX sch whack my son's head with a text book.
A teacher in XXXX sch asked my daughter to stand on the chair just becoz my daughter wore a black clolorful bra.
oh hell grammr problem -
i cant believe nowaday education is such a failure? teachers have to spare the rod n spoilt the students?
last time when i was in primary school, my teacher caned the whole class of students when the class was noisy. i was not even talking also got cane.
there was another teacher who was sadist, he use thumbtap to pin students' vein when they r laughing.
another female teacher who is a sister nun used karate chop on student's spine.
when i was in secondary, a teacher slapped those hooligan students when they tried to talk back or rude to them.
using book n hit students were too common, one of my teacher even ask one of students to jump out of window becos he thought the student was beyond hope. -
i feel that teachers can punish students, because thats always the case when students do the wrong thing. But shouldnt they tell the students what wrong they do or the reason for punishing them? Sometimes its just very frustrating when a teacher punishes you and keep mum about WHY he/her punishes you. Thats awful. For one to bear the consequences, one needs to know the cause in the first place like i always said.
-
when i was in primary school, if my teacher pinched my ear, i would tell my mum........
-
there is a reason why people keep quiet. especially in the army.Originally posted by jojobeach:Who , you ? Why you so stupid kept quiet for so long ?
you will know the reason when why you start to realize why you keep having guard duty on public holiday eve, Saturday and Sunday.
if you dun know also never mind. you can try complaining. -
this i agree. why cant the teachers just treat the students as their customers. they are paid to educate them, ONLY in terms of knowledge, not behaviour. social studies is just a past time to the students. have IQ very good liao, dont care about their character being good or not.Originally posted by jojobeach:Why do we allow a teacher to hit children ?
Are teachers holier than any stranger in the street ?
Why couldn't teachers do what they are paid to do, impart knowledge, and leave the discipline part to the parents ?
i really pity these pampered children. they think they are right and everyone else is wrong. They will not be able to learn! i heard from my friend who is a teacher that now teachers are only allowed to write positive testimonials. It is NOT allowed to have a single bit of negative description. Like if the student is talkative and not paying attention, you can describe him as expressive, intellectual.
Can you believe that? they are all deceiving the students and their families? how to expect them to have great achievements when they are living in their own world of praises??
-
Originally posted by jojobeach:Mr Lim Lao Peh,
How do you know he is not emotionally affected by what the teacher did ?
Just because he is a kid does not means he is without pride and ego.
Yes it is true, what he did reeks of vengence. But it is better than internalizing the hatred within himself. And we wonder why some kids goes into his own school and randomly kills . Think.
By publishing the name of the teacher and the school.
The school in-charge will inevitably have to look into this matter and provide some answers to what had happened.
Do you really believe TS will not have to deal with dishing out the truth when that happens ?
Nothing is a molehill when teachers whom we trust our children to, strikes a helpless child.
i really piity your kids. not as you would need it..
i have been in the working society long enough to realise that i cannot only listen to one side of story. it may seem so believing, but you need to know the other side of the story too. it is very unfair to judge a book by its cover. if you want to comment, find out the other side before you prove your stand. If not, it is better to keep quiet and let the others do the talking. -
not say that many of us here prefer to be beaten by teachers. If it is a good cause you had understood to be your own mistake, accept it with open heart and keep shut. if you think it is unreasonable for the teacher to beat you, you should at least wrote the whole story to let others judge who is in the wrong. ny concealing the other side, you are trying to avoid the problem/s that led to the beating.Originally posted by Boy Stratus:"Last time my teacher slap me" "Last time my teacher kick me" "Last time my teacher throw stuffs at me"
Hello?! Who cares about last time. No one complains what teachers did last time doesn't make it right this time. Last time, maybe some students want to complain but afraid to, or doesn't know the proper way/person to complain to. So they have no choice but to let it go. The sh!t we gone through doesn't mean that the others need to suffer from it too.
We should try to stand up & help the students instead of bringing up how the teachers have abused you previously & compare it, brushing it off using the excuse of "Only an exercise book so its okie."
Although it's just an exercise book, but that is not the point of whether she is using a light weight object or a heavy one. It's the way the teachers sent the message across to students that counts. The teachers can jolly well give him detention rather than hit him.
Tho i think TS should have complain to the school 1st or something. -
i think Spore may have kept quiet for some matters, but for those with concrete proof, government will fight to the end. my own opinion is that spore as a tiny little dot, if give and take can save spore trouble, just be it. But to some matters concerning the reputation and alike, govt will do what they deem fit.Originally posted by Hellraiza:How about saying something new? This line has been done to death in this thread by all the strong and silent types who made nary a whimper when they got hit by their teachers, even though they, just like the TS, conveniently forgot to share what they did to deserve such treatment.
Your teachers hit you and you guys kept silent. So Singapore should have also kept quiet when Malaysia contested Pedra Branca lah?
Wankers....
govt is not perfect of course, but they are not all bad to us. unless you like USA or big countries where you do not know maybe next minute you be shot by your fellow student. -
even nsf nowadays like to complain n cant take hardship =/
-
i gotten 2 slaps from 2 teachers before,isnt that more worse?