I quite agree with Li Ka Shing. It was somewhat uncomfortable to be reading all the encouragement for you to take the hard line because this could very possibly have the opposite effect to what you really want. This is a family we're talking about and your parents seem like the kind of people who will support all their children in difficult times. They probably see something behind your sister's current behaviour that you're not seeing, especially if her behaviour has only deviated these past three years.Originally posted by Li Ka Shing:Hi mumof2,
I have a suggestion. Please bring ur sis to a psychiatrist. She might have negative schizophrenia. This is a condition where someone loses motivation, is withdrawn, loses schedules/ structures, etc. I think it's quite possible ur sis might be suffering this illness. Especially all ur descriptions, how she stayed up until 5am, seldom able to hold work, etc.
Just get her checked first. Ok?
Originally posted by Saint`:n if any case it might be psychiatric .. but why did it evolve till such a blown up stage?? 31 yrs old already leh
Originally posted by Li Ka Shing:Hi mumof2,
I have a suggestion. Please bring ur sis to a psychiatrist. She might have negative schizophrenia. This is a condition where someone loses motivation, is withdrawn, loses schedules/ structures, etc. I think it's quite possible ur sis might be suffering this illness. Especially all ur descriptions, how she stayed up until 5am, seldom able to hold work, etc.
I disagree with the suggestion to make her move out, cut support, etc like that. Becoz I think it's not productive. If u cut support, she might not be able to stand on her 2 own feet. Just get her checked first. If she's indeed having this illness, cutting support is not gonna work coz she's not like other normal people who can stand on 2 own feet when forced.
As a sister I think u are having a big pressure but ultimately u still love ur sis and please just get her checked first instead of cutting support or anything like that, coz I think it will ruin ur family ties for the future. Ultimately u want to save ur sis and ur family and I think u should think of the best solution and be wise.
Ur sis will never agree to go to hospital on her own accord. You have to think of a creative way, or persuade her somehow. Then, accompany her there, u and ur mum. You and ur mum should talk to the psychiatrist as well.
If neccessary, ask for a test, a written test. That will be more accurate. But the psychiatrist might be able to tell without any tests. And then, ur sis will take medication for at least 1 year. But believe me, ur sis will change. From then on she will really do change.
I think this is one way u can really save her and get her back as ur sis, and save ur family/ parents, urself, without ruining family ties for the future.
Trust me.
Just get her checked first. Ok?
Originally posted by F Bunta:
What are 'principles' and 'attitudes' when you can't even fill your own tummy?Originally posted by mumof2:You are right. We have to give her the ultimatum. I have already spoke to 2 of my close friends to look for jobs. I am looking for other job openings now for her: and ask her to take up one of them. If not, computer will be confiscated and by 1 month no job, get lost.
I can't believe I actually knelt down and begged her to go to work years ago. She was smiling like nobody's business. I really hate her for what she has not done the past years. I am a person who will work hard even from scratch. I thought about how I work and slogged from a small position. She is HAOCHI LANZUO, she thinks she is right all the time, she upholds her own "principles" and has attitude problem. She would argue at the slightest remark and always insist she is right. I even thought about getting a social worker or councilor to talk to her, but where to get help? and who would help such parasite who is physically capable?
Now me and my mum are at loggerheads. She thinks I treat her like a maid as she gets such megre pay. I told her thats all I have. If she wants money go ask that wretch.
Originally posted by Li Ka Shing:Hi mumof2,
You can take her to a psychiatrist, and then I think it's better to ask for a written test. Ask for MMPI-2 or whatever the psychiatrist recommends.
From ur sis email reply, and how ur mum said ur sis wanted to suicide, I think u know ur sis is having a huge pressure, just like u having pressure. Maybe u might want to reduce the pressure a little, to ur sis and to urself. In the meantime, get her checked and about the entry-jobs thing, well why don't u ask ur sis to send a CV which doesnt say she's a journalist? Yeah, don't let the company knows she is overqualified. Simple.
Originally posted by starblue:i have one question... why are you trying to resolve this ONLY NOW??? she is 31, and i bet she has been like that all the way till now.. why hadnt you all made attempts to correct her??? i dunno, be the situation looks bleak. she has more or less fixed her character and all that, how to help??
Originally posted by starblue:i have one question... why are you trying to resolve this ONLY NOW??? she is 31, and i bet she has been like that all the way till now.. why hadnt you all made attempts to correct her??? i dunno, be the situation looks bleak. she has more or less fixed her character and all that, how to help??
Not to that extreme please... You're doing your part and you certainly have your own children to take care of....?Originally posted by mumof2:I argued with her alot over the years, even before I was married. She is often shielded by my mother and then its just another day gone by. The circumstances was so bad at that time. My parents were younger and I was busy working and dating too. We were financially stable at that time. Incomes are also coming from both my parents who then have their own small business. She failed to get admitted to nus after A levels, so my mum pushes her to study a private degree course which she failed too. After stopping for a year or two, she expressed interest in continuing her education. But she was further discouraged by enrolment problems as she stopped too long. I even urged her to go for a computer course which I will pay for but she reject it due to "non interest in this area". Finally, she did her Diploma in Mass Com. My then boyfriend (my hubby) even arranged for her to do some office work in his office. she did well but it is a temp job. We have been trying to help her. We tried to let her see what people we are associating with and how we live (our lifestyle). But she is very stubborn and her bad lifestyle emerged very very quickly. I am not stereo-typing here. I live a normal life like anyone here. The one thing I regret is that I introduced online chat to her for fun. She has been obsessed since. As much as I love music, I really couldn't understand how she could stand having the music turned on for almost 24 hours a day.
She even emailed back that "its not like you are paying $1000 to mother every month" (she is indicating that its not a big sum i am contributing anyway). Isn't that money?? I couldn't believe this words manage to come from her. She does not appreciate that the bills are all paid by this "not a big sum" for so many years. Its better than she is not contributing at all.
I was paying my mum $1000/mth until the birth of my baby no. 2. $800 this year and recently $600 every month. My dear husband tries to cheer me up and calm me down but we all know problem will not go away unless my parents stop shielding her and she changes her attitude.
I am a person who loves good food, travel and live a good healthy life. And I hope my parents are able to enjoy these too. Unfortunately, I am not capable to provide these alone. I had sacrificed my career for my children and did not expect she will be jobless for so long.
I think one day I may need to see the psychiatrist first because I get more depressed these days just by argueing with her and my mother. Sometimes, I think I am better off dead so that this reality will tell her your sister is dead and you gotta work.