Ch U Superstar rating system seriously flawed?

• NuLife

  8 Jul 05, 00:06

  I think so absolutely.
  
  They shud limit 1 Sms vote per HP number.
  Else those from rich families/friends wil surely win.
  
  Today's results really made me vomit man... esp F4.
• hisoka

  8 Jul 05, 00:10

  isn't it the same with all the voting systems for these idol copies?
  
  anyway i really wonder how many pple go and waste money to call, feel like they cheating money for the charges they charge, personally wont call
• www

  8 Jul 05, 00:13

  no one wins.
  
  mediacorp + telcos win.
  
  still got survival round somemore.
  then the fans will revenge with more sms. telcos win more.
• www

  8 Jul 05, 00:16

  i wonder how come they dont learn from NKF and give out prizes to attract more sms...
• Maurince

  8 Jul 05, 00:17

  kaoz~ sad man
  singaporean needs to dig their ear man..
  disappointing result..
  last week that guy.. now poor kelly..
  haiz~ haiz~ haiz~~
• Lethargic@@

  8 Jul 05, 00:17

  couldn't agree more...telco wins all...
• 798

  8 Jul 05, 00:20

  Originally posted by www:

  i wonder how come they dont learn from NKF and give out prizes to attract more sms...

  like that lagi worse... nowaday votings have to become tis ways to earn revenue for telcom, see until so pissed.
• deathscythe99

  8 Jul 05, 00:38

  Originally posted by 798:

  like that lagi worse... nowaday votings have to become tis ways to earn revenue for telcom, see until so pissed.

  Who has more money, wins
• Nelstar

  8 Jul 05, 00:50

  Originally posted by 798:

  like that lagi worse... nowaday votings have to become tis ways to earn revenue for telcom, see until so pissed.

  Hey, this isn't fresh news.
  
  Remember those days when 9.58fm host the 'Long Hu Bang'?
  
  Remember you actually had to cut out coupon from then 'Dian shi guang buo zhou kan' the magazine with the size of an exercise book?
  
  Hey it was even worse back then, imagine how much the 'dian shi guang buo zhou kan' actually cost. It was so pricely that only the rich are voting. SMS is far cheaper and convenient leh.
  
  
• F.raon.I.R

  8 Jul 05, 01:30

  omg.....today's rusults really turned me off COMPLETELY!........fuck la
  kelly n weijian r the better 1s in the competition hu really can sing especially kelly.....
  n wat happened?! haizzzzz....the guy hu got the lowest score was thru..but can oso see that he was oso very surprised.i dun like that ruth...so short n fat...she can't really sing.juz smoke thru.n ya she forgot her lyrics.....
  last week there was oso 1 guy hu sang wanglihong's song.he got the highest score n was oso knocked out...wat!!haizzzz....we should go 4 quality man!!singaporeans!!!!!!......really need to dig ears liao.....
• octega

  8 Jul 05, 01:37

  Bo pain, the votes lies in the hands of the viewers, as most posts here already state.
  
  The "riches viewers" will get the say.
  
  Personnally, I feel that the judges should have atleast 50% or more say in the final results. They are afterall professionals (or atleast 2 of them, the rest of the 3 I dunno wat the heck they are there for).
• Nelstar

  8 Jul 05, 01:40

  Originally posted by octega:

  Bo pain, the votes lies in the hands of the viewers, as most posts here already state.
  
  The "riches viewers" will get the say.
  
  Personnally, I feel that the judges should have atleast 50% or more say in the final results. They are afterall professionals (or atleast 2 of them, the rest of the 3 I dunno wat the heck they are there for).

  What makes a real star is not the quality but the packaging and sellability nowadays.
  
  Remember Jenny from the block.
  
  She sings as well as me. Or she croaked as well as me?
  
  
  
  Oh yea, I know what you wanna say. Sex sells.
  
  
• ditzy

  8 Jul 05, 01:41

  Last time, lucky draws allowed photocopied entries to be sent in, so I see no detrimental effects now.
• Nelstar

  8 Jul 05, 01:46

  Originally posted by ditzy:

  Last time, lucky draws allowed photocopied entries to be sent in, so I see no detrimental effects now.

  Now, am I borned too late?
  
  
• stellazio

  8 Jul 05, 01:49

  oh man..and my school actually put his face asking us to support wei jian..now he's out..how saddening..haha..
• Nelstar

  8 Jul 05, 01:53

  Originally posted by stellazio:

  oh man..and my school actually put his face asking us to support wei jian..now he's out..how saddening..haha..

  You should be happier that he's out early, and you are not supporting him till the last straw when the last opponent is a TCMI (totally cannot make it) sure-die wont-win ugly-looking toad-sounding crap and your wei jian lose by 1 vote.
  
  That's very saddening.
  
  Hey, I am helping you to visit this event in a positive way.
  
  
• stellazio

  8 Jul 05, 01:57

  corrections..i don't even watch the show..so i couldn't care less..LOL..but i pity him cuz lots of people from my school were telling me how good he is..duno whether izzit becuz of patriotism or real talent..something like the daphne case in sg idol..but at least that i prefer to watch...haha..he'll probaly come abck to school like a big shot..
• NuLife

  8 Jul 05, 01:58

  Originally posted by octega:

  Bo pain, the votes lies in the hands of the viewers, as most posts here already state.
  
  The "riches viewers" will get the say.
  
  Personnally, I feel that the judges should have atleast 50% or more say in the final results. They are afterall professionals (or atleast 2 of them, the rest of the 3 I dunno wat the heck they are there for).

  Its those contestents with the rishest family and friends that will win.
  they really shud do something abt this.
  That F4 really sucks big time and shud be out.
  No looks and cannot sing or groove.
  
  
  I feel almost all those kicked out shud be brought back.
  not only do they have more talent, but looks too.
  
  The judges/programme director really shud do something abt this.
  Forget all those rules and keeping their 'faces' against any U-turn decisions
  I believe this time, a U-turn is necessary if they want to win fans back
  to the show.
  
  
  
• stellazio

  8 Jul 05, 01:59

  wtf i went to my school webpage..he's the singer in the song composing club??? damn that dude he really can sing,he sung for some business event in which i was involved in as well as many others..he and he's band is talented..oh damn now i know why so many people are crying foul...wahahaha..that guy is talented.
• Nelstar

  8 Jul 05, 02:00

  Originally posted by stellazio:

  corrections..i don't even watch the show..so i couldn't care less..LOL..but i pity him cuz lots of people from my school were telling me how good he is..duno whether izzit becuz of patriotism or real talent..something like the daphne case in sg idol..but at least that i prefer to watch...haha..he'll probaly come abck to school like a big shot..

  He already won.
  
  People will want to know him. They will want to put him on their friends' list.
  
  And after winning the attention for a while... things start to die down.
  
  Say twenty years later... nobody actually remember this superstar crap show was about what.
  
  
• tjb

  8 Jul 05, 06:35

  wher did channel I go?
  
  taken down by MediaCorp?
• Mr Fugue

  8 Jul 05, 08:07

  can't believe u all still got watch....
• sgboy2004

  8 Jul 05, 08:10

  at the end, the winner so wat... cos got more smses ...
• Mr Fugue

  8 Jul 05, 08:16

  Originally posted by sgboy2004:

  at the end, the winner so wat... cos got more smses ...

  where is taufik now??
  
  all winners from what star searches, talent time, whatever contests...etc., where are they now???
• sgboy2004

  8 Jul 05, 08:16

  Originally posted by Mr Fugue:

  where is taufik now??
  
  all winners from what star searches, talent time, whatever contests...etc., where are they now???

  he is in his bed sleeping now