kelly vs weilian in stadium. what a turn-off!
-
take a good look at the current chinese entertainment scene.
tell me how many real good singers there are. they are mostly packaging. most cant sing. singing is not just about good vocals. record companies sell albums to make money, not for arts!!!
they only support singers who are marketable.
there is one thing very peculiar about the chinese scene. those with good looks aside the popular singers are mainly those with high vocals.
i am inclined to believe wei lian won not just through compassionate votes but because of his high vocals.
many of the current superstars are either good looking or have high vocals. -
there are many people with disabilities whom are better than a totally abled person. stevie wonder is an example. he is better than many many other singers right?Originally posted by Axelheat755:i feel that most ppl are feeling so negative is because the show is looking for a SUPERSTAR, not a singer. A superstar is supposed to be able to look good, sing well, dance etc and weilian, unfortunately, dun really fit in the picture.
Not that anyone is against handicap but seriously, do u wish to have someone from another country laugh and say " OMG!! The best u guys can come up with for a superstar is a blind guy !?"
there is nothing wrong with having a blind buy as a superstar, if the recording company is agreeable.
subconsciously you are biased against people with disabilities. -
2 all those who think they r sympathy votes, wat makes u so sure they r sympathy votes? & 2 those who criticize this & tat, why dont u guys go & participate in the contest? the world is a cruel 1, & 2 set the record straight, a very unfair 1. if not, why some ppl r born with silver spoon & some have 2 slog all his/her life working 4 the "silver spoonie"? superstar is a popularity contest. whoever catches the viewers hearts, whoever gets the vote. simple. jus like sg idol. u think sly deserves 2 b in last 2? gdness sake he cant even pronounce!!! but, the ppl luv him enough 2 vote & make him the top 2. its not jus the singing ppl r voting 4. its the whole package. 2 make things simple, if kelly was some fat ulgy short pimple face chick, do u think ppl will vote 4 her even if she has a gd voice?
-
the chinese singing scene couldnt have made it more clear.
what heavenly kings and queens? 99% of them only have looks.
gimme a break!!! -
Bloody Hell!!!Originally posted by dragg:there are many people with disabilities whom are better than a totally abled person. stevie wonder is an example. he is better than many many other singers right?
there is nothing wrong with having a blind buy as a superstar, if the recording company is agreeable.
subconsciously you are biased against people with disabilities.
Your post count.....*shake hand*
What do you do everyday? You got work or not.
Cheers -
unemployed.Originally posted by M©+square:Bloody Hell!!!
Your post count.....*shake hand*
What do you do everyday? You got work or not.
Cheers -
What do you do?Originally posted by dragg:unemployed.
Hint: Go and be Jun Yang's agent. Then the rest won't be angry with Wei Lian.
Cheers -
if junyang has won he will only add to the already crowded boys band class of singers.Originally posted by M©+square:What do you do?
Hint: Go and be Jun Yang's agent. Then the rest won't be angry with Wei Lian.
Cheers -
actually u all shouldn't blame on WL. u should blame on urself for not voting for JY
-
I won't commit the same mistake. Will vote for WL this time round.Originally posted by makiko:actually u all shouldn't blame on WL. u should blame on urself for not voting for JY -
In what capacity are u to judge his singing...u are just one flamer in this forum....what a lame to criticise...look at Stevie Wonder, he is definetely a superstar and a legend...unless you dunno what is the meaning of superstar...Originally posted by gimdavid:ya, heng also not like you! just to symphatize for the sake of sympthasize so can make oneself less 'guilt' in the sense..
blind is blind, talent is talent, it is totally separate issue.... again, i have said that i am not against handicap.. but one blind man beat all the contestant, and not that his voice is fantastic than the rest.... -
Wah....so fierce!Originally posted by soloken:In what capacity are u to judge his singing...u are just one flamer in this forum....what a lame to criticise...look at Stevie Wonder, he is definetely a superstar and a legend...unless you dunno what is the meaning of superstar...
-
he can have a lot of fan at the contest but when the CD come out, will all his supposed fans buy it?Originally posted by findingnewidea:i think you miss the point - superstar is based on fans support. this comes from the 70% vote from the fans. Can' you see that?
A person can be very good but no fans support (extreme case). Can he/she be called superstar?
AI 2 is the example. Ruben won but clay aiken cd sold more den his. does that say anything? -
weilian is straight..
he always say..' if u dont like me u dont vote for me..'
but still he can make it this far..
i perfer him over jy .. -
blame blame blame!!! human only knw how to blame ppl. should actually blame on their mother who give birth to them in the first place
-
i feel that ..jy too similar to JJ...
no orginality.. ( how u spell this ? heck..)
we dont need so many of this kinda
too many in the market already...
at least..wei lian is fresh..he got a diff voice...
pple listen to him..know its him..
eg.ah du..
-
Who blame who?Originally posted by makiko:blame blame blame!!! human only knw how to blame ppl. should actually blame on their mother who give birth to them in the first place -
there will be no end to this cause of diff opinion. The example i quoted is just one of tem. IMHO, i think weilian did'nt sing that well, but...Originally posted by dragg:there are many people with disabilities whom are better than a totally abled person. stevie wonder is an example. he is better than many many other singers right?
there is nothing wrong with having a blind buy as a superstar, if the recording company is agreeable.
subconsciously you are biased against people with disabilities.
just make sure that when they come out CDs, u go support them -
u not temp mod meh?Originally posted by dragg:unemployed. -
some one also blame her GM and even cursed them and family included even when her tax bracket is in the 2000+++ dollar range.. pot calling kettle black...
-
not keen on temp job.Originally posted by Axelheat755:u not temp mod meh? -
just now 9:50
933 on air got du jia liao
from their cd..
tong hua n yi shi de mei hao
very nice ! -
Sorrie not meant to be harsh, when I look at the comment make by the judges, can sense that they are more for Junyan, especially on the second song english and when Weilian sang that, I find it very nice...unfortunately Feihui make the first comment and followed by Jean Yip (worst judge of the all, only how to copy peoples line). But I do agree feihui in certain area but the song sang by Weilian touches me and it does bring back memories whereas Junyang boyband song is just too common. Nothing to stir up people's emotion.Originally posted by M©+square:Wah....so fierce!
Well I guess the comment make affected Weilian's performance but overall the meaning of Superstar is to capture the heart of the audience and it does not necessary mean the younger generation but throughout different age group so I guess Weilian does touches me, and that is his charisma which JY probably lack in that...
cheers -
apparently a weilian fan lolOriginally posted by M©+square:Wah....so fierce!
im a fan of neither, i just post my views 
-
i wont call or buy any albums, regardless of the winner.Originally posted by Axelheat755:there will be no end to this cause of diff opinion. The example i quoted is just one of tem. IMHO, i think weilian did'nt sing that well, but...
just make sure that when they come out CDs, u go support them
it is not even important to me who wins, though of course i believe kelly is more marketable.
i am more concerned about whether my opinion will eventually proved to be right.
just to satisfy me curiousity.