Originally posted by newmanmback:
perhaps you can give a detailed description of the testing procedure and what software required. so i learn it next time i will not insist on warranty. so far all the hdd i buy no prob....just need to arm myself before i get one got problem.

so when u replace the ahdrdisk u brought your testing lappy or computer there tell them got prob and they connect it up to a comp and format no prob can use how? i dun know got shop assistant so good one to one exchange based on your "test". i tell u what, i go change one to one the shop assistant tell me go maxtor, seagate, samsung, hitachi, WD rep tell them bad and have it looked inito
well...its ur cash so whether U want warranty or not is up to U..
for me...no warranty=no buy.
testing procedure is nothing special...just do a scandisk with ur windows OS and see if there is any bad sectors or not...or if it can be detected by ur system in the first place....if U dont want to use the windows one...can use 3rd-party diagnostics tools like norton and etc...download.com got a lot of these programs.the main purpose is to make sure there are no bad sectors...or the number of bad sectors is within the range that U find acceptable...
In my experience with HDDs...either personal or at work...if the problem is really on ur HDD...there is no way it would work perfectly when U couldnt get it to work at home....PROVIDED that U installed it correctly and there is absolutely nothing wrong with ur own setup...removing ur WORKING HDD and replacing it with the new one and then test it is one way...but do take note that some HDD failure occur intermittently...difficult to detect...so there is always risk involved if there is no warranty.
well...if U really meet such a retailer...depends on ur quarrelling skill?...I havent met with such a situation before...I go back and change...they auto change for me...especially when I go back on the same day...so normally when I buy HDD....I make sure I have the whole day free...alternatively...there are always ways to make ur HDD non-workable

...