Should the Hwa Chong student be suspended?
-
kolleck...Originally posted by allentyb:HCI and ah beng also human, why can't treat this case, equally and fairly, why should we give that boy a second chance, where, what he did, was violence assault, what he has done, is no different from a ah beng, so if people can't see it that way
so be it
-
he was crying and shivering while calling his dadOriginally posted by Darkness_hacker99:I mean after the punch, he didn't run away right, He's waiting for the cops to come right?
of course the bus driver must have threaten to call the police
its too late, at that time, to feel remorse
if you actually look at this matter, point by point, you will realise, the naiveness of those teenage who never give a damn to this society, and when they commit an act, then they feel remorse, nobody will give a damn, because this world is realistic, why should we give him a chance, and since he is from a reputable school, shouldn't he be more educated, this is price of being in an elite school, you should lead by example, but now, he has been bought back to earth, and face the music -
Originally posted by Darkness_hacker99:He say he not purposely punch de..
I did not purposely steal.....
Still jail, cane & fine?
Arbo let me fcuk your gf and then i say i didn't fcuk her on purpose....you like it? -
this reasoning actually shouldnt holdOriginally posted by Darkness_hacker99:I guess the boy will get lighter sentence because he's good in his studies.
Few months ago also got one case of dunno what, then the judge sentence the guy lightly because of his studies.
it makes the sting of elite-get-it all even worse -
Like that call "Fair & Equal" ah?Originally posted by Darkness_hacker99:I guess the boy will get lighter sentence because he's good in his studies.
Few months ago also got one case of dunno what, then the judge sentence the guy lightly because of his studies.
Then the judge is fair or unfair leh???
A judge needs to have justice wor... -
If he explain in a polite way I may give him my card..Originally posted by 798:actually i will like to ask all wat happen if the bus uncle takes away your concession card claiming it was stolen or expired?
wat will be your reaction? feeling boil? or confuse? i believe most of us will be extremely unhappy right? the problem is this kid is from an elite sch dat made pple want to pin the sch down.
for the kid who took the wrong move for losing his head n chose violence, he is going to pay for his crime. but he is so young and his future will be gone for being impulsive.
-
so, impolite = ????? punch?Originally posted by Darkness_hacker99:If he explain in a polite way I may give him my card.. -
thing is we do not knowOriginally posted by dcx:so, impolite = ????? punch?
and even if it is, it does not mean that chap can punch and kick
i think this case is so simple but how come people make it so confusing? -
It's some kind of good background that help him reduce his sentences.Originally posted by gigabyte14:dat means minor can get away scot free?
y does the government have to protect him so much? just because he has a good record? just because he's an elite?
the parliament is corrupted.
Compare future talent with chao ah beng, which one will get lighter sentences. -
how about, next time, you are impolite to me, does that give me the right to punch you in the faceOriginally posted by Darkness_hacker99:If he explain in a polite way I may give him my card..
then when the police take my statement, i tell the police, sorry i never had the intention to punch him, but he was rude to me -
Dunno leh....Originally posted by laurence82:thing is we do not know
and even if it is, it does not mean that chap can punch and kick
i think this case is so simple but how come people make it so confusing?
Becoz some ppl dun wan the elites' future to be tarnished/punished but for ah bengs, they deserved to be tarnished & punished?
Come on....where's the fairness, equality & justice wor.....
Next time if i got chance to take bus, i dun pay my fare....
BC not happy with me, i also not happy, then i punch.....
But depends on if the punishment which will be fell onto the student, will i then do the similar as what he did.....
"I not stupid Episode X" -
eh....you never encountered or know that got chao ah bengs/lians in the end got a PhD or businessman, making millions & talents working under them mah?Originally posted by Darkness_hacker99:It's some kind of good background that help him reduce his sentences.
Compare future talent with chao ah beng, which one will get lighter sentences. -
I won't loss my temper for no reason de.Originally posted by allentyb:how about, next time, you are impolite to me, does that give me the right to punch you in the face
then when the police take my statement, i tell the police, sorry i never had the intention to punch him, but he was rude to me -
you are not answering my questionOriginally posted by Darkness_hacker99:I won't loss my temper for no reason de.
but i will not force you to answer -
No I dont.Originally posted by dcx:eh....you never encountered or know that got chao ah bengs/lians in the end got a PhD or businessman, making millions & talents working under them mah? -
no one is suspending the future elites. it is just like destroying the government's future.
-
so, impolite = ????? punch?Originally posted by Darkness_hacker99:If he explain in a polite way I may give him my card.. -
i have to agree with chin eng, u just register to post this? nothing better to do is it. be more sensible. we KNOW this news way longer than you do and we're just pointing out the pros and cons and u are here, saying we are losers. wat does that make u, a loser's loser. grow up kid and READ CAREFULLY before you post.Originally posted by eothian:You guys are losers.
Click here for full story : http://newpaper.asia1.com.sg/printfriendly/0,4139,130301,00.html -
somehow u are rightOriginally posted by DarkMatter:no one is suspending the future elites. it is just like destroying the government's future.
we focus so much on the future of the good students, we tend to think bad students have no future and have no chance for redemption
if those defenders of that HCI student says this is not the case and insist on giving that chap a counselling and such, i suggest all 'bad' students records be erased and in the future all such cases students be only given counselling
only then this will be fair -
well. if our singaporean future elites are suspended. it may be ok to the government, they are introducing foreign talent elites to our country.Originally posted by DarkMatter:no one is suspending the future elites. it is just like destroying the government's future. -
Originally posted by laurence82:
well u should know that the government is introducing foreign talents to singapore. if the people of singapore do not work hard, the government don't care. there are alot of foreign talents coming anyway each year and in a few years time, every 2 or 3 pple u see 1 will be a foreigner. foreign students work harder so the government don't care if you don't study well and back out in the future. but i agree with what u say, if the HCI student keep being defended, all the 'bad' students' record should be erased.
somehow u are right
[b]we focus so much on the future of the good students, we tend to think bad students have no future and have no chance for redemption
if those defenders of that HCI student says this is not the case and insist on giving that chap a counselling and such, i suggest all 'bad' students records be erased and in the future all such cases students be only given counselling
only then this will be fair[/b] -
impolite does not give one's authority to punch. juz because someone is impolite that another person should punch him. they might as well say rudeness = kickOriginally posted by dcx:so, impolite = ????? punch? -
this thread going to be thread of the year..
-
indeed, this has reached 31 pages in just 4 days. it reaches 32 pages soon =/Originally posted by club18:this thread going to be thread of the year.. -
Definitely no argument thereOriginally posted by dcx:I suppose the truth is that that boy did punched the BC with witnesses around.
Is that reliable enough? 
The question is how it came to a punching match.